Showing posts with label Yorkshire. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Yorkshire. Show all posts

Sunday, 25 June 2023

County Championship Round 8: Yorkshire v Gloucestershire, 25/06/2023

 

 

County Championship Round 8

Yorkshire v Gloucestershire

Preview

After a disappointing, but not unexpected Blast campaign, it is back to Championship action with Gloucestershire starting the run-in to the end of the season in 7th, now 38 points behind the promotion places after consecutive defeats ended the unbeaten run.

With promotion now looking extremely unlikely, barring an astonishing run of form in the last six games, the main focus of the remaining games is to avoid the wooden spoon. The Leicestershire game, last time out, was a severe reality check, with a strong position lost in a volley of attacking shots and then the bowling attack struggling to exercise any threat. It led to a defeat that had seemed unthinkable with two sessions to play.

As in 2022, the injury crisis among the bowlers has been quite astonishing. With the first-choice attack rarely, if ever, available over the last three seasons and a squad that has less depth than most, even in Division 2, it is hard to carry players who are feeling their way back to form and fitness. In the Leicestershire game it was obvious that Tom Price and Ajeet Dale were not fully match fit, but they had to play anyway and that was a key factor in defeat.

With David Payne still unavailable for red-ball cricket, Ajeet Dale injured again, and Danny Lamb returned to Lancashire, one of Josh Shaw, Joe Phillips and Grant Roelofsen will be in the final XI: probably Josh Shaw to give a 4-man seam attack of Tom Price, Matt Taylor, Zaman Akhtar and Josh Shaw, supported by Zafar Gohar, although this leaves the tail longer than one would wish. The alternative relying on Ben Charlesworth as fourth seamer to fit in Joe Phillips or Grant Rolofsen as the extra batsman looks less likely. However, given that this campaign seems unlikely to supply the success that the club hoped for pre-season, there is a strong argument for playing Joe Phillips sooner rather than later.

Ahead is a Yorkshire side still struggling in the lower reaches of Division 2 and desperately needing to string together a series of victories. They won both games in 2012 when both sides were recently relegated to Division 2 (both games were close, though) and split the two games last season in Division 1. A draw will suit neither side, so expect both to go all-out for the win in what are likely to be hot and batsman-friendly conditions.

Day 1

Yorkshire won the Toss and, unsurprisingly, elected to bat. Gloucestershire, decided to pick Grant Roelofsen to bat at 3, going with three front-line seamers plus Zafar in the first game with the less responsive Kookaburra ball. Yorkshire had a side with some unfamiliar names in it, including the Surrey spinner, Dan Moriarty, at Headingley on loan.

Tom Price took the New Ball with Matt Taylor. The pitch looking surprisingly green and, under scattered, high cloud and intermittent sunshine, using the New Ball well looked to be critical. First impressions were that Tom Price still looked down on pace, as he had against Leicestershire. He went for six boundaries in his first three overs: the first a controlled edge through the three Slips, followed by three Cover Drives that Sir Geoffrey himself would have approved of. 33-0 from the first five overs and it was evident that this was going to be a hard day.

In truth, there were far too many four-balls waiting to be hit, something that went on all day: it was partly batsmen still on T20 mode, but a lot of it was the bowling not being tight enough. 55x4 and 3x6 in the day was too many boundaries.

What no one expected after such an explosive start was that Adam Lyth would half leave the first ball of Matt Taylor’s third over and guide a gentle catch to Ollie Price who took it diving to his left: a soft wicket and a gift to the bowler. He then pinned Shan Masood third ball, without scoring. Suddenly it was 33-2 and Matt Taylor was on 2.4-1-8.2. It could have been even worse for Torkshire. Dawid Malan edged his first ball between 3rd Slip and Gulley: it went for four, but could have as easily have gone to hand.

The relief was brief. Tom Price, whose first three overs had gone for 25, was replaced by Zaman Akhtar. Rather than stopping the scoring, he went for a brace of boundaries and four byes in his first over. Matt Taylor also went for three boundaries, and, after 8 overs, the score was 61-2, a scoring rate more familiar in the Blast. Even though some quiet overs followed, including consecutive maidens, the introduction of Zafar in the sixteenth over was met gleefully by the delightfully named Finlay Bean, who swung him for a six and a four. On came Ben Charlesworth to spell the front-line seamers. He surely could barely believe how Dawid Malan glanced his first delivery – not the best that he has bowled in his career – through to James Bracey. 90-3 and Gloucestershire taking wickets despite the frantic pace of scoring.

Graeme van Buuren was changing constantly the bowlers in an attempt to make something happen, using six in the first session. It did slow the scoring somewhat from its peak of 7.62 runs per over to 4.79 per over at Lunch, but it was Yorkshire’s session. Twenty-one year old Finlay Bean, who has been playing in the 2nd XI in recent weeks, in just his ninth First Class match since his debut at the end of last season, a menacing 65*. 139-3 from 29 overs, with 24 fours and a six. Frenetic stuff, although nothing like the mayhem at Leicester, where Durham were putting the hosts to the sword.

Matt Taylor and Zaman Akhter in tandem after Lunch as the clouds built and showers started to form around the area. It was not long before Zafar was back into the attack, Miles Hammond with his new and quite singular hairstyle (a crew-cut, dyed a pink that is now fading unevenly), donning the shinpads and helmet at Short Forward Square Leg. Zafar could not engineer the breakthrough and, although mostly he kept a lid on the scoring, an expensive over including an under-edged cut between Wicket-keeper and Slip and a six over Mid-wicket as George Hill danced down the wicket persuaded the Captain to bring himself on as seventh bowler. Meanwhile, the Yorkshire fans were the only ones laughing as Mr Bean moved smoothly into the 90s, while George Hill brought up his own 50 and then the team’s 200, hooking Tom Price to the boundary.

Finlay Bean clipped Ben Charlesworth for a single to move onto 99 and, in the same over, pulled the bowler through Square Leg to bring up his second First Class century from 140 balls. We saw a piece of daft cricket immediately after. Bean advanced down the pitch, mistimed his shot and, still out of his ground, but not attempting a run, Zafar threw the ball back, apparently attempting the runout. The throw took Bracey completely by surprise saw the ball run for, fortunately, only a single overthrow – which earned Zafar a lecture from the umpire (you cannot be runout if not attempting a run). However, this may just have unsettled the batsmen. Zamam Akhtar dropped one short, Bean pulled, and Ben Charlesworth took a fine, tumbling catch on the boundary. Finlay Bean out for 114, just short of his First Class best score of 118. 243-4 and the match still moving on like an express train.

Luck was not quite on the side of the bowlers, though. George Hill edged Zafar inches short of Slip and Gloucestershire were agonisingly close to making it 251-5 and starting to get some control. Instead, Yorkshire started to build again. 273-4 at Tea, Hill 77*, Tattershall 25*.

Post-Tea, it was a matter of steady accumulation and grinding down the bowlers. Up came the 300 and the second batting point. The scoring slowed, but the landmarks came: the Tattershaw 50 with a somewhat ungainly pull for four off Tom Price. Hill’s century followed soon after with a clip off his legs to Ben Charlesworth on the Square Leg boundary (177 balls, 13x4, 2x6). Yorkshire closing on the 350 as the second New Ball approached. Charlesworth offered too much width and was cut to the boundary to bring up the 350, two overs before the New Ball was due. With 1-59 from 9 overs, Charlesworth was struggling in the fourth seamer role and presenting the captain with a problem as he could use Charlesworth to block up an end and rest the main seamers. This though was an opportunity for Ollie Price, who came back just before that second New Ball. Hill edged him through to a jubilant James Bracey. 354-5. A bonus wicket on what was proving to be a tough day and Ollie Price with two excellent catches and a wicket to boot.

The second New Ball was taken immediately and given to Zaman Akhtar, a sign of the struggles of Tom Price, who you would have been expected to be offered it first. Fifth ball, he took the edge of Revis’ bat but, again, the ball dropped just short of Second Slip. However, the second New Ball did bring a wicket as the admirably persistent Matt Taylor, who was both economical and threatening, got the edge from Tattersall and Ollie Price brought off yet another excellent catch at Second Slip: 368-6 and a second bowling point.

The floodlights were beginning to shine more and more brightly and, inevitably, 8.4 overs into the second New Ball, the heavens opened and a the groundstaff scampered to protect the wicket. 388-6.

The shower was short and sharp, and after a quick clean-up, the players came out for 2.2 overs and five more runs added. 393-6 at the Close, with the ground bathed in bright sunshine once again.  Maybe not Gloucestershire’s worst day of the season, but far from their best and a substantial score already for the batting to chase and still three wickets to take with overs running out for full batting points. Matt Taylor, with 17-7-43-3, by far the best of the bowlers.

Day 2

When I posted the Day 1 report on social media, one loyal fan came straight back with “yes, it’s a season of struggle, isn’t it?” Certainly, although not plumbing the depths of despair that the supporters felt at this stage last season, it’s not what we had hoped for. Those promising positions of early season in which you felt that only rain robbed the team of a couple of wins have changed into positions where you hope that rain will come back and save the team (stick with that thought: it could happen). At times on Day 1 it looked like a battle between two sides short on confidence who were desperate to attack at any cost. The attack at all costs theme continued, but Gloucestershire were less successful at executing it than their hosts. Another day, another fine mess… but hope of salvation is still there.

It's a truism in sport and, in particular, in cricket, that eight players can carry three, but three players cannot carry eight. Even the great West Indian side of the 1980s had players like Milton Small and Larry Gomes who have been forgotten by 99% of fans, while even Allan Border could not carry the Australian side of 1981. There are some fine players with (deserved) international caps in this current Gloucestershire side, but three seasons of constant injury crises causing an XI that chops and changes from match to match in an attempt to paper over the cracks is no way of building confidence, or of nursing players back to form.

Today’s problem was to take three wickets quickly for full bowling points, limit the damage, hopefully to around 450 and then bat well in what should be favourable conditions. Yorkshire had the fifth batting point in sight. Bright sunshine. Matt Taylor with the still fairly new ball.

Matthew Revis opened with three runs from a ball guided to Third Man, but it took just two more deliveries for Matt Taylor to induce an edge from Matt Fisher that James Bracey pocketed gleefully. A wicket with the fifth ball of the morning! Unfortunately, Matthew Revis was still there and built a handy partnership with Dom Leech. After a quiet start, he warmed to his task with boundaries off Matt Taylor and Zafar then reached his 50 (86 balls) with a single of Charlesworth. When Zafar strayed down leg, Revis launched him far over Square Leg. That left 4 overs for bonus points, the score 442-7. Gloucestershire needed a miracle to get the third batting point, while Yorkshire knew that they would get the final batting point just pushing for singles. The talk now, given that rain was expected on Days 3 & 4, was more about when the declaration might come. On came Ollie Price to try his luck. He broke the stand – two balls after the 110 overs had ended – thanks to a stupendous catch from Miles Hammond, who took a one-handed grab, diving to his right. Meanwhile, in other news, the 50 partnership had come up and then the 450 with a slog from Leech that could have gone almost anywhere but ended up flying over Mid-On. Was this the start of a push for a declaration? There was a flurry of boundaries but then, again, the pace slowed as the 500 approached with Ollie Price and Graeme van Buuren getting through overs rapidly in tandem.

Enough of this frivolity, decided Revis, who carted GvB over Wide Mid-On for six and, next ball, sent a delicate dab down to Third Man for a boundary. His point made, it was back to the singles to bring up the 500 in the 117th over. From there, until Lunch, every scoring shot but one off the bat was a single.

531-8 from 124 overs at the break. Matthew Revis on a menacing 94* and the looming suspicion that, unless he falls soon, Yorkshire would try to push on to 580-600 before declaring.

The afternoon started with the Gloucestershire “Z-formation”: Zaman followed by Zafar. Once again, the session started well, although it took eight deliveries, instead of the five of the morning session to take a wicket. A quiet over from Zaman, then Mark Steketee danced down the wicket to Zafar, was completely done in the air and James Bracey had the bails off in a flash. 534-9.

Matthew Revis was way past his previous First Class best and, on 99*, produced a sumptuous Cover Drive off Zafar to reach his century from 162 balls. Dan Moriarty then got off the mark with a superb drive all along the ground through Mid-Off to bring up the 550 and, finally, after 130 overs, the declaration came.

So, the pitch had dried out. The green tinge had almost disappeared. Could Ben Charlesworth and Chris Dent make use of it?

Just six runs from the first five overs as the batsmen started cautiously. Four Slips waiting hungrily. Chris Dent pulled Leech through Square Leg and the cracked a very wide delivery through Point for two boundaries in an over in the first signs of aggression. With Ben Charlesworth acting as sheet anchor, Chris Dent went for his shots, outscoring his partner 3-to-1, going hard at anything too wide. It was the wide ball that was his downfall: he drove hard at Dom Leech and edged the ball straight into the midriff of Alex Lees at Second Slip. 45-1, Dent 34 and another promising start cut short, taking his season’s total to 315 runs at 26.3.

Fifty up in the 17th over. Could Charlesworth and Roelofsen take advantage? Eleven from a Leech over as Ben Charlesworth cut consecutive boundaries through Point, then hit a massive six back over Dan Moriarty’s head. Moriarty has an unusual approach, running a few steps, then stopping and walking before jogging into his delivery stride. He was generating respect. Just two scoring shots – one of them that six – had come from his first four overs. Roelofsen pressed forward against him, missed, and was pinned right in front of middle. 80-2, Tea and some of the shine was coming off the start.

In came Miles Hammond, a player who needed a big score after a rather mediocre first half of the season.

Flat pitch. Men around the bat for Dan Moriarty. What would Ben Charlesworth do? The answer was to jump down the pitch and hammer the ball past the Silly Point, who must have felt the wind as it passed. The next delivery was cut the other side of Silly Point, who was surely thinking that there are better ways to pass an afternoon than be a coconut in a coconut shy. Charlesworth, though, went for one shot too many and edged to Slip. The batsman stood his ground, thinking that it was a bump ball. The umpires consulted and Charlesworth was sent on his way. 93-3. Charlesworth 35 and another nice start cut short.

The score continued to advance rapidly, if not at quite such a pace as yesterday. Graeme van Buuren unleashed a straight drive for four followed by a six over Cover as he tried to hit Moriarty off his length. The theory was fine, the practice was something else: another big shot, a thin edge, and a fumble from Tattersall, but the ball dropped back into his glove. Moriarty with 3-33, 125-4 and Gloucestershire in familiar trouble. Runs coming at 4-an-over, but wickets falling. Still the attack was taken to Moriarty. Miles Hammond was the next to dance down the pitch and launch him back over his head for six. Up came the 150 in the 37th over: just 301 more needed to avoid the Follow-On. Another skip down the pitch and Miles Hammond launched another big six back over Dan Moriarty to go to 39 and have top score in the innings so far. You would have bet good money that if Miles Hammond got to his 50, it would be with a six of Dan Moriarty. It was. Thumped over the Covers. Adam Lyth came on to twiddle some occasional off-spin and Miles Hammond sent him into the stands at Long-On to move to 64 from 70 balls. The 200 up in the 46th over, with James Bracey batting nicely in support.

With Moriarty in front of him, could Sherlock Hammond solve the case of the missing centuries? Eleven overs to the Close, stand at 75. Don’t give it away now.

Eleven off an over from Leech, including a boundary from a horrible misfield and Hammond had Lyth in his sights again. Whack over Long On. Hammond on 74. If only someone would stay with him.  James Bracey was batting so confidently but was deceived by a bit of turn from Lyth and edged to Slip. 44 and yet another batsman who could not make a start count. 221-5. Not what the team needed shortly before the Close.

Miles Hammond reached 79 from 81 deliveries with yet another boundary and could have reached his century by the Close, but he and Price decided the discretion was the better part of valour and wisely slammed on the brakes.

232-5. Hammond on 84*, Ollie Price 1*. And rain forecast for the ‘morrow. For once, rain will be eagerly anticipated and cheered.

If a lot of time is lost there is even an intriguing prospect that Yorkshire could try to set up a chase of perhaps 350 on the last day.

Day 3

Heavy rain and the first session hit on its head quite quickly. Everything depended now on how much rain fell and for how long, but with three potential end-games:

·       Yorkshire go for the innings win. The last 5 wickets fall. Yorkshire enforce the Follow-On and try to bowl out Gloucestershire again on the final day.

·       The captains agree to set something up. Gloucestershire declare behind after obtaining 2/3 batting points. Yorkshire go for quick runs to set up a chase.

·       Gloucestershire save the Follow-On and the match fizzles out.

A 14:15 start. One session lost. 62 overs to bowl. The light, gloomy.

Gloucestershire played positively from the start. Miles Hammond was quickly into the 90s with a big six over Long Off from the second delivery of the day, Dan Moriarty again the victim. That was his seventh of the innings in addition to his 5x4. He then went for an eighth and was caught just inside the Long On boundary. It was not the brightest cricket, and the mystery of the missing Hammond centuries remains, but it was still an excellent innings. However, at 246-6, 304 behind, Route 1 seemed to be the most likely way to get a result. The business of obtaining any batting points, was again falling to the tail and Yorkshire were anticipating a quick finish to the innings. With the shadows of the floodlights dark and the umpires getting twitchy, off came Matt Fisher and on came Adam Lyth. The message was obvious: bowl your spinners or we go off.

Ollie Price must have been very close to falling LBW to Lyth but then, next ball, received a filthy delivery that was very wide indeed. Using his long reach, he just about got to it and flat-batted it through the Covers to bring up the 250 and the first batting point. Soon after, when Dan Moriarty gave him one in his zone, Ollie Price joined the “I’ve hit a six off Dan” Club, the ball hammering into the advertising boards at Long Off. The 50 stand came up with a reverse sweep by Ollie, who was batting really well and in the same over, a single from Tom Price for a shot that almost went to hand brought up the 300 and the second batting point. Shortly after that, the players were off for bad light at 300-6.

It was to presage an afternoon of “on-off” hokey-cokey.

The delay was not a long one and the sides were back out rapidly. Immediately the Prices set about reducing the deficit. An on-drive for three brought up Ollie’s 50. Sixteen from a Steketee over – three consecutive boundaries and a ball sprayed down leg for four byes – took Ollie to 70 and helped to bring the 350 closer and three boundaries in the following over from Matt Fisher for Tom Price saw the third batting point come up and the deficit drop under 200. A lovely drive just past the stumps brought four more to Tom Price. Consecutive overs had gone now for 16, 12 and 14 runs. The hundred partnership came up in a blaze of runs.

369-6 at Tea. 181 behind. The partnership 123. Ollie 75*. Tom 37*.

Back out after Tea, it wasn’t “Blazing Saddles” with John Wayne, it was more blazing floodlights and blazing bats with Tom and Ollie. And a tactical decision was coming up: the Follow-On looked certain to be saved; should Gloucestershire try for the 5th batting point and declare to force Yorkshire to try to score quick runs?

The batmen were seeing the ball well enough, but out came the light meter and off they trooped once more. 384-6. Ollie 82*, Tom 45*, 17 to avoid the Follow-On.

It looked terminal but, at 17:20, off came the covers and back on came the players. Time, though, was running out to reach 450 and declare and get some overs in before the Close. The draw loomed ever-larger. A Square Cut for a boundary took Ollie into the 90s, the score to 398, and brought up the 150 partnership. Successive straight drives had been stopped by a diving Mid-On but, finally, Tom hit one a bit straighter, just out of his grasp, to bring up his 50, the 400, save the Follow-On and add the 4th batting point: good value for a single shot. The next delivery was hooked imperiously into the stand at Square Leg. Tom then made a cross-batted swipe to the next ball and had his stumps re-arranged to give a no-nonsense sequence of 4 6 W. 408-7.

Zafar did not last long. He ducked a bouncer “periscope up” and glanced the ball to the ‘keeper. 413-8. 12 overs left, 17 remaining to get 37 runs for a 5th batting point. Ollie had his First Class best score: could he make it a century? A clip off his legs was stopped on the boundary and took him to 96. Then a single. 97. Matt Taylor guided the ball through Third Man for four, then was hit by the last ball of the over. That persuaded the umpires to check the light again and off they went. 421-8, Ollie 97*. And that was that.

With potentially only 92 overs left if there are two changes of innings and a sleeping pitch, a draw now seems inevitable. Gloucestershire will now surely bat on to try to see Ollie Price to his century and to get the 5th batting point. It is hard to see how, without declaration bowling, Yorkshire can get far enough ahead to set up a realistic chase. Any declaration target would need to be something like 350 from 70 overs: it is hard to see it happening now.

Day 4

Had Gloucester been bowled out perhaps 180 behind we might have got an interesting finish with Yorkshire batting again to chase quick runs and give their bowlers a rest. Gloucestershire’s success with the bat has, ironically, removed their slight chance of a win in a last day chase. The only realistic course now is to bat on for the 5th batting point, if possible, with Yorkshire looking for a third bowling point and to accept the draw. Even with declaration bowling, it is hard to see how a target can be set and time enough left on a completely placid pitch to bowl a side out. A declaration game can, realistically, only be won by Gloucestershire, so there would be no incentive for Yorkshire to set one up.

Another grey day, although some blue sky was visible and there was an on-time start. Ollie Price on strike and on 97. Four defensive strokes, a ball down leg, a glance and the ball rocketed to the boundary to bring up the century 145 balls (15x4, 1x6). What a find the Price brothers have been.

First ball of the second over of the day Matt Taylor gave a thick edge to 1st Slip and Yorkshire had their 3rd bowling point. Gloucestershire were not showing the urgency that suggested that something had been agreed but advancing steadily in search of 450. A lovely straight drive from Zaman Akhtar took him to 11 and the score to 437-9. The sight of a #11 batting comfortably was enough to suggest that no way would 10 wickets fall in the day, let alone 20!

A Cover Drive from Zaman Akhtar and up came the 450 and maximum batting points in the 102nd over. Ollie Price then edged the last ball of the over, just past Slip, for 3, Finlay Bean producing a fine diving stop on the rope. This was the logical moment to pull out had the captains agreed anything but dream on… they batted on. Seeing Zaman Akhtar make his First Class best score with some ease showed that this pitch remained a bowlers’ graveyard. Finally, Ollie Price played a swipe at Moriarty and lost his leg stump. No red-inker for Ollie. 113 and the Shire 464ao. Dan Moriarty with 5-139.

To make a game of it, Yorkshire would need to be bowled out for no more than 150. It was not going to happen.

Five overs were enough to show that the two sides had agreed the draw. No rush from the batsmen at all. And no great encouragement for the bowlers, although the ball was doing a little more in the overcast conditions. Tom Price was looking livelier and went past the outside edge of Bean’s bat, producing a huge shout that was turned down. At 29-0 from 10 overs, the match was going nowhere. Zafar had loud appeals for bat-pad catches by Miles Hammoind at Short Forward Square Leg (correctly) turned down from consecutive Zafar deliveries, but really, there was little to get excited about.

72-0 from 18 overs at Lunch and rain expected later.

There was just enough in the pitch that if Zafar could keep it very tight, he had a chance of something. Plenty of balls were flying into the air off the pad and being appealed for enthusiastically. Finally, just three balls into the afternoon session, one did take the edge. Bobby Bracey juggled it and caught the rebound. Bean out for 38. 73-1. He almost got a second when Shan Masood top-edged a reverse sweep and the ball dropped just short of the diving Ben Charlesworth running in from the boundary. Adam Lyth reached his 50 and then edged Zaman Akhtar low to Slip where Ollie Price took a good, tumbling catch. In the next over Shan Masood tried and missed consecutive reverse sweeps off Zafar: the second flattened middle stump. Zafar was delighted, the score was 135-3 and the wilder optimists were wondering if this was the start of a declaration charge. However, the skies were getting darker, the floodlights were on, and the forecast rain seemed to be getting closer.

Finally, at 148-3, the umpires decided that the light had got too bad, and the covers came on, followed shortly after by rain and the large sheets. With just 50 overs to go and the lead 234, there seemed to be little point in coming back on later.

Early Tea and a re-start at 15:40, with 43 overs to play. Gloucestershire searching for wickets to end on a positive note. Ironically, now there was some real help for Zafar, who beat Dawid Malan all ends up with a delivery that turned sharply: the ball slid through for four byes, the ‘keeper unsighted. To the next ball, he swept and missed. The three-card trick was completed by another sharply turning delivery that he tried to cut, inside edged and Bracey caught after a little juggle. 160-4. Ben Charlesworth came on and, first ball, Jonny Tattersall edged, and Ollie Price took the catch at the second attempt. 161-5, 38.5 overs left, 247 the lead. Another quick wicket and perhaps Yorkshire might have got nervous. Hill and Revis had other ideas and brought up the 200. 31 overs left. Can we go home now? After handing over his glasses to the umpire, Chris Dent came on to bowl, apparently seam-up. Third ball, George Hill edged, Ollie Price caught. Hill sank to his knees in disbelief. Chris Dent held his face in his hands. It was only missing a McEnroe-like cry of “you cannot be SERIOUS!” This was Chris Dent’s first, First Class wicket for four years.

A few spots of rain came down. Had there been anything hanging on the match they would have stayed on, but it gave Yorkshire the chance to declare at 16:50, by which point the covers were off again. The nominal target was 289 from 28 overs, but the captains had the good sense to shake hands instead.

12 points for Gloucestershire and some confidence from, again, holding the initiative at the end. A maiden century, two wickets and five catches for Ollie Price. Another fifty for his brother. Signs that Gloucestershire had a handy pair of all-rounders developing.

Saturday, 24 September 2016

County Championship: Of Champions and Contrived Results


 

County Championship

Of Champions and Contrived Results

September 24th  2016

So, after some remarkable events over the last four days, Middlesex have been pronounced Champions. A match that was dying and that appeared to have been killed the previous day, suddenly came to life in mid-afternoon of the last day of the season, with the Trophy seemingly coming off the Taunton exit of the M5 after an inexorable three and a half day trip from Headquarters.
On one level there will be some serious soul-searching and a few complaints that it is a tarnished victory for Middlesex.

That point of view is absurd.
Middlesex went top of the table on July 6th with a big win against Yorkshire and were never headed [save briefly in the penultimate round when they were 2 points behind, but had a game in hand]. At that point, after 9 games, the Middlesex lead over Yorkshire was 15 points (Yorkshire with one game in hand) and over Somerset, more interested in not slipping into the relegation battle, 25 points.

Victory against Somerset in the next round of games left Middlesex 38 points ahead of Yorkshire and 45 ahead of Somerset (look how their nearest challengers on July 13th, after 10 games, were Warwickshire and Lancashire, both of which entered the last day under real threat of relegation and watching anxiously the events at Southampton).
Somerset gave a hint of things to come by winning their next two games against the free-falling Nottinghamshire (themselves top of the table after 4 rounds – a quarter of the season) and Durham.

On August 16th, Middlesex were 26 points clear of Yorkshire, having played a game more and 35 points clear of Somerset, also with a game in hand.
September 3rd. Games in hand played out. Three matches left. Middlesex still top, 4 points ahead of Yorkshire, 21 points ahead of the rapidly rising Somerset.

September 14th. For the only time since taking over at the top on July 6th, Middlesex were headed when Somerset beat Yorkshire and, Middlesex, with a game in hand, momentarily found themselves a full 2 points behind Yorkshire and 1 point behind Somerset.
At this point, bearing disaster in their last two games, Middlesex were virtual Champions, given that even two, high-scoring draws would be likely to win the title. Victory at Old Trafford would all-but-seal a thoroughly merited title. Middlesex supporters know  though that their side is likely to shred nerves at any moment. How right they are!

Old Trafford. September 12th. Middlesex bat and are 151-1 in the 50th over. With plenty of forcing batting to come, 350 looks certain, even 400 in 110 overs requires little more than 4-an-over from there. A partnership of 97 in 34 overs for the third wicket made the 5th batting point unlikely, but the 4th, should have fallen. What happened was a slow crawl as the enormity of the situation seemed to paralyse the batting: even the 300 and a third batting point was just, barely reached inside 110 overs with James Franklin and Toby Roland-Jones just barely scrambling over the line before Middlesex subsided to a disappointing 327, taking up almost four sessions to do it.
Even then, the go-slow seemed irrelevant as Lancashire slipped to 6-4. Not too many people have Toby Roland-Jones on their list of likely England bowlers, but when he is on song with the new ball he can be very destructive and is extremely consistent. However, the Middlesex bowling has also shown an alarming tendency not to follow through on early breakthroughs and to let opponents off the hook. 6-4 became 32-5, 138-6 and 230-7. Even though Lancashire themselves collapsed from 230-6 to 250ao, another 100 overs had been taken out of the game, only around 4 sessions remained and Middlesex needed to add to their lead… FAST! The collapse to 55-4 was the last thing that they needed. 140 ahead on the last morning and knowing that a quick wicket would open up a real chance of a Lancashire win, acceleration was out of the question until it was far too late. There was never a realistic chance of setting a target and the game died.

The two batting points surrendered by Middlesex radically changed the situation for the last round. Instead of being 12 points clear of Somerset and able to win the title with a high-scoring draw, the difference was 10: a draw would offer no guarantees if Somerset passed over the corpse of the relegated Nottinghamshire, on what seemed certain to be a sporting Taunton pitch.
Here, things muddy a little.

Somerset were to face the already relegated Nottinghamshire who had lost four of their previous five matches. With the game at Taunton and recent pitches there offering low-scoring minefields on which Jack Leach and debutant Dominic Bess had caused chaos (in the Warwickshire game, the innings had lasted 30, 49, 74 & 58 overs respectively, with Bess taking 6-28 in his debut innings), no one doubted that there would be a result, possibly in well under three days. Middlesex had to face Yorkshire on the low, slow Lord’s pitch which, all season, had produced a series of pretty turgid draws.
Photographs of the Taunton pitch at the Toss showed a surface that suggested that a two-day finish was as likely as the match stretching into a third day. This though was, if anything, good news to Yorkshire and Middlesex fans as it appeared unlikely that Somerset would take any batting points: with a 19-point win, Middlesex would need just 10 to win the title: score 250, take the bowling points, avoid defeat and the title would go to Lord’s.  For Yorkshire, matching the Somerset result would be enough.

Just possibly this feeling that a relaxing draw would be enough on a reliably low and slow Lord’s pitch, influenced what was to come. Even the fact that this was the same pitch that had produced an utterly one-sided One Day Cup Final did not dispel the feeling that there was no need to take the slightest risk when a draw would suit nicely.
The combination of a 1030 start, bowling conditions, tight bowling and a pitch that did not allow quick scoring at any stage plus, undoubtedly, some Middlesex butterflies, led to an arthritic crawl to 270ao. Add in overs lost to bad light (desperately slow over rates, leaving Middlesex at -8) and some rain (which duly arrived later in the match) and Middlesex were leaving themselves painfully vulnerable rather than seizing the moment. Do not do anything positive. Take the draw. Middlesex though were getting close to the point where the points deduction for a slow overrate might even lose them the title.

It was gripping. It was a titanic battle but, you could almost hear Geoff Boycott muttering “those dopy so and soes. There’s more brains in a pork pie.”
All the more so because, despite being able to field two Test bowlers in Imran Tahir and Samit Patel, Nottinghamshire let Somerset reach 300 and three batting points before finally waking up. Five wickets fell at 322, Somerset crashed from 302-2 to 322-9 but, in a final indignity to a Nottinghamshire side bereft of any self-confidence, the last pair were allowed to add 43, bring up the fourth batting point and ensure that Somerset were likely to take a 23-point win, totally changing the dynamic of the title race.

Only the fact that Somerset failed to enforce the follow-on stopped the match from finishing in two days. Even some heavy rain was never going to send the match into a fourth day.
With Somerset 13 points ahead and also ahead on the first tie-breaker (most wins, 6-5), a draw was no use to Middlesex and Yorkshire now needed a 23 point win as they were behind on the second tie-breaker (most defeats, 1-2), surely there would be some positive cricket at Lord’s?

Although both sides would probably deny it, there seemed to be a little bad feeling between the sides. Yorkshire were very aggrieved that Jonny Bairstow was not released and then Adil Rashid dropped out of the match (it turns out that off-field issues left him in no mental state to play). Middlesex, in contrast, had all their players available, with Tim Murtagh released for the game by Ireland. With Andrew Strauss calling the shots, one could understand that there was maybe a little paranoia going into the match. Then Nick Gubbins had edged behind on 97 and not walked. Had he been given, Middlesex might well have been dismissed for a little over 200. Other chances were dropped. A few marginal decisions went the Middlesex way. If you were Andrew Gale and walking a disciplinary tightrope it must have been really tough to take. It meant though that Yorkshire were in no mood to do anyone any favours at all.
Yorkshire’s chances of the title seemed over when Toby Roland-Jones had Lees, Ballance and Gale all for ducks. With Lyth out for 43 made from 53-4, you felt that Middlesex could win the natural way and settle the title race. Not a bit of it.

Same as in the previous game against Lancashire. Tim Bresnan, batting at #5, although with a career batting average near 30, added 116 with Hodd. Then 35 more with David Willey and when Nick Compton returned the favours received by dropping a sitter from Rafiq and the pair dug in, Middlesex must have felt that it was all over.
When Middlesex’s only chance of keeping the match alive was to allow Yorkshire to reach 350 quickly and keep them interested in the result, they continued to apply suffocating fields. Killing the game meant playing everything on an agreed declaration. Overs 98 to 107 took the best part of an hour out of the game and produced just 10 singles and 50 dot balls, as the Yorkshire last wicket partnership edged (literally, at times) to the promised land of 350. Surely Middlesex would have been better off had he had one of his bowlers offer a couple of juicy half volleys, or maybe a couple of balls that just happened to slip down leg (so sorry, ‘keeper!)

Murtagh, Roland-Jones and Finn produced an eye-watering 405 dot balls between them in the innings.
When you start your second innings 120 behind with just four sessions left, you rather expect a draw. When you then fall to 2-2 and are left to hobble to the Close at just a fraction over 2-an-over, you start the last day knowing that you will need the best part of an hour to reach parity, before even thinking of setting a target. On the final morning Yorkshire had a real chance to take a couple of quick wickets and set up a simple chase.

A quick calculation also showed that even if Middlesex scored at 4-an-over – well above anything achieved in the match so far – any declaration would not come until after Tea, with a target of around 220 from 25 overs. If you were a Somerset fan, only a clatter of early wickets seemed likely to disturb your road to a first ever title.
Lunch. 201-3. Middlesex lead 81.

Half an hour after Lunch. 210-3. Middlesex lead 90.
Middlesex would say that they were ensuring against defeat, but this was just ludicrous.

55 overs left. Lead 95 and the new ball about to arrive.
50 overs left. Lead 115. 20 from the last 5 overs is an improvement, but there is no danger of a result this way. And Middlesex are facing a hefty points deduction for a slow overrate that requires them to get back out and bowl some overs quickly.

239-3 from 85 overs. Middlesex have shown a little more urgency with 22 from the last 4 overs, but the match is still going nowhere fast. However, Andrew Gale either has a chronic stomach problem or even he has realised that what is happening makes no sense and is going off to negotiate with James Franklin, returning with an offer that is rejected and then trying again and again to get an agreement.
Lyth comes on to bowl: 4 4 4 6 . 4

Then Lees: 4 . . W (Jack Brookes, you idiot! What a stupid moment to take a blinding catch)  4 1
Lyth again: 4 4 4 4 4 .

Lees, a better over: 6 1 6 W (bowling a straight one though was a bad mistake) 4 6
74 from 4 overs has helped a lot, if not done much for the dignity of the game.

From here it is a matter of hitting the agreed two boundaries per over and defending the remaining balls. 46 from the next 5 overs and James Franklin signals the declaration by deliberately sending the ball straight up into the air for the bowler. How else does one declare? Maybe by putting on a silly hat and playing the Joker from It’s a Knockout?
240 from 40 overs looks a very generous target, but that run-rate has only been reached in the last 10 overs of pie-chucking so, in reality, it looks like an act of desperation for Yorkshire to accept it. For most of the game even well-set batsmen have struggled to reach 3-an-over. The only question seems to be whether or not Yorkshire will shut up shop if they are well short with 7 or 8-down.

It did not take long for the answer to come. Yorkshire were never close to the run-rate required. Tim Bresnan was the only batsman to score at the required run-a-ball. By the time that it came to 153 from 20 overs, the writing was on the wall: with 10 wickets in hand, fine; when it is only 7, you need everything to go right and cannot afford an accident. Once Bresnan (to a marginal LBW) and Gale fell in quick succession it was all over. Yorkshire knew that they could not win. Somehow it was appropriate that the end was brought with a Toby Roland-Jones hat-trick as Yorkshire decided to swing on and hand the title to Middlesex rather than shut up shop and give it to Somerset.
Seven thousand paid at the gate to watch. Probably a couple of thousand more watched as members. Who says nobody watches the County Championship?

Of course, this being Middlesex, there was a sting in the tail in the form of a 4 point deduction for slow over rate. How many points the Middlesex scorer has saved his team this season by negotiating away negative over rates no one knows: it is generally reckoned that if the over rate is -2, he can get it back to zero and thus save a two point deduction. A conservative estimate is that the scorer has saved his side some 20 points over the season: the difference between being Champions and finishing 3rd.
Hollow victory? Middlesex beat Yorkshire twice and beat Somerset at Taunton. They went through the season unbeaten and four of their eight wins were achieved away from home, while dead pitches at Lord’s made winning there almost impossible. Despite a slow start – their first win did not come until their seventh game and then to relegated Hampshire – with Middlesex starting that game only just above the bottom two, three wins from four matches in mid-season saw them rocket up the table from seventh to top and put down a marker. The chasing pack – Warwickshire, Lancashire and Durham – all faded, Middlesex did not. No other team could sustain a challenge. Somerset left themselves too much to do. Yorkshire, though affected by Test calls, never gave the impression of invincibility that they had in the previous two seasons. No, Middlesex were worthy winners. No other side could have claimed as much.

Sunday, 13 September 2015

Amazing Matches Show What The Fans Will Be Missing When The County Championship Ends


 

The County Championship Throws Up Another Surprise

 

September 13th 2015

 

As we reach mid-September, a significant fraction of the population realises that, soon, something very important will be missing from their life. The cricket season is ending and, with it, something that has filled our days for almost six months.

Today is the final international match of the season. An England side, unsurprisingly written-off my many in April – let’s face it, who in their right mind would have predicted that England would finish the season with an overall winning record in Tests and that it has every chance to finish with an unbeaten series record in all formats this summer?

On September 20th, the surprise package of the season, Gloucestershire – a team that many fans think should disappear in a Championship with a reduced number of First Class counties – will take on a Surrey side that has persistently underachieved for years but which, finally, looks to be building a formidable side for an assault on the top flight, in the One Day Cup Final. While no longer the occasion that it was in the ‘70s and ‘80s, a Lord’s Final still means a lot to players and fans. More about that another day.

The County Championship though, is what most fans will miss. Sixty-four days of passion and emotions. This season has broken an extraordinary run of seasons where there has been incredible tension down to the last session of play. Yorkshire were crowned Champions and Surrey and Lancashire were promoted mathematically with two rounds to play. The main doubt is whether Lancashire, runaway leaders for most of the season, will go up as winners of Division 2 or Surrey, 54 points behind on June 16th, will pip them.

A measure of what fans will be missing has been the extraordinary events of the last four days at Lord’s. Middlesex completed one of the great comeback wins of all time to send Yorkshire crashing to their first defeat of the season. That in itself would be remarkable, but Middlesex were 0-3 after just six deliveries and bowled out for 106, conceding a first innings lead of 193.  At 145-5 second time around, 48 behind, the match should have been over that night. Somehow though Middlesex put on 440 runs for the last five wickets and knocked the stuffing out of the Champions, who capitulated tamely on the final afternoon, with a noisy crowd cheering and singing all the way.

As Middlesex were fighting back as similar story was being told at Trent Bridge, as Nottinghamshire came back from a deficit of 168 to beat Durham and Hampshire produced an extraordinary escape to come back from 390 behind on first innings and keep their survival hopes alive with a draw at Taunton. Try telling the players in these three, extraordinary matches, that the Championship does not matter and produces low-quality cricket. No other First Class Competition in the world is as tough, or as well supported.

Although the wooden spoon will mathematically become Leicestershire’s again in the next round of games, even they have won two matches and made real progress, to give their fans something to cheer.

The two issues that remain are the minor places in the Championship, although it will take something pretty amazing to stop Middlesex and Nottinghamshire being second and third respectively and Warwickshire to take fourth with its not-to-be-despised prize money. Poor Durham: runaway leaders, 29 points ahead of Warwickshire and 33 ahead of Yorkshire on June 18th, they have taken just 37 points from their next 7 games, losing six of them and look set to finish out of the money. Indeed, Durham look set to finish only just above the relegation zone.

Only wins in their last two games can save Worcestershire and not just wins: it is quite possible that even two, twenty point wins will not be enough; hope for them comes from the fact that they play free-falling Durham on Monday, although at Chester-le-Street where batting points are grudgingly won. Hampshire too, need at least one good win and a high-scoring draw and even then will depend on Somerset or Sussex to finish badly in their last two games. Given though that they play each other starting Monday and could all but see themselves safe with a high-scoring draw, it will be interesting to see what pitch is served up at Hove.

It is not yet impossible that we may be served-up more last evening of the season drama like last season when Lancashire, needing a win to survive and send Middlesex down instead, backed Middlesex up against the wall, only to be denied in extremis by Chris Rogers.

Ah, Middlesex!!! Who, seeing their desperate plunge down the table last season from early pace-setters to a desperate last afternoon struggle for survival, would imagine that they would be Yorkshire’s closest challengers? Not for nothing were they many people’s tip to be relegated, as the Middlesex fans are reminding everyone with some relish. And they have done it the hard way.

Looking at the bare details, seven wins and only one defeat (to Champions, Yorkshire) looks pretty good, but then look how those wins have been achieved:

·         Only 5 times in 15 matches have Middlesex taken a first innings lead.

·         Middlesex’s average first innings score is under 250 – they have thrown away around 25-30 batting points.

·         In 7 of 9 completed innings, Middlesex have scored more runs in the second innings than in the first.

Middlesex’s success in 2015 has come on the basis of a stuttering batting line-up, far too dependent on tail-end runs from the likes of James Harris and Toby Roland-Jones. Seemingly all season it has been getting into a hole and then counter-punching, often through an 8th or 9th wicket stand, to recover a desperate situation after a top-order failure.

Whereas Yorkshire can boast eight batsmen who average over 40 and five more who average over 30, Middlesex have just three averaging over 40 and three more averaging over 30.

Five bowlers for Yorkshire have taken at least 25 wickets, while only four of the Middlesex attack have done so, yet Middlesex are finding ways somehow to win games, helped by the extraordinary figures of James Harris (69 wickets @ 24.6 and 455 runs @ 25.3, including 3x50) who needs 45 runs in his final game of the season to reach the modern all-rounder’s double of 500 runs and 50 wickets in the Championship.

Despite a huge number of Test calls that have robbed them of half their side at times, Yorkshire have been able to dig into a seeming bottomless array of talent and reserves and are deservedly Champions. No one would argue that they have been far and away the class side of the year yet, for all their problems (struggling openers, a shaky middle order and the lack of an attacking spinner), Middlesex though have got closer than anyone could ever imagine. After years of underachievement, could it be that Middlesex will get it right finally in 2016? Middlesex, being Middlesex, their supporters will know to expect the unexpected from their side: maybe 2016 Champions, maybe relegated.
 
The tens of thousands of passionate supporters of the County Championship will count the months until more thrills and spills start again next April. However, with the uncertainty about the future form of the Championship, 2015 may be the last one in which we see it in its present form.