Thursday, 14 November 2013

Things Start To Fall Into Place


 

 

Ashes 2013

 

The Most Satisfying Day of the Tour

 

November 14th 2013

 
 

After trips to Perth and to Hobart that must have left the England squad wondering “is your journey really necessary”, today has been a really satisfactory day. Having watch the Cricket Australia Invitational XI get weaker by the day as player after player was withdrawn to play in the Sheffield Shield, there had been a fear that, between weak opposition and the forecast bad weather, this match would be of as limited use for serious preparation as he previous two. When the Australian top order, with Ed Cowan and Aaron Finch at its head imploded so spectacularly there was a fear that the bowlers would not get the hard workout that they needed, trying to winkle-out well-set batsmen when the ball was doing little or nothing. In particular Broad and Swann needed some hard overs.
When Carters and Neville did exactly what England needed them to do and showed some backbone, the headlines were, predictably, that it had been a pretty bad day at the office. All that though was put in context by what followed. When Broad took Carters first ball of the day, 271-5 rapidly became 304 all out. Four cheap wickets for Broad. Five for Finn. And what is even more important, at least 22 hard overs for every bowler, with Finn topping 28. The argument about the attack for Brisbane has been settled.

The Invitational bowling attack though is probably not much stronger than English County 2nd XI. Lalor and Tremain, the new ball attack, had just five First Class matches each and 18 and 16 wickets respectively coming into this match, both at averages around 30. The one thing that did not go to script was that Michael Carberry fell cheaply however, he has so many runs already that it hardly matters. After that, Cook, Trott and KP made merry. Jon Agnew described KP’s wicket as “bored out” – having hit the ball to all corners for an hour and a half it was time to give someone else a go and get on with something more taxing, like reading a book.
Having reached parity by the Close, with the batsmen scoring at 4-an-over, Joe Root and Jonny Bairstow were enjoying some middle time, with Root looking set for another 50 batting at 6. The experiment of Root going back to the middle order seems to have revitalised him.

Even the weather is starting to help England. The bad forecast for tomorrow has improved considerably and there is a likelihood that there will be most of a day’s play. Ideally England would like to see Root and Bairstow get their fifties and then declare around lunch, before seeing if the bowlers can provoke another top-order collapse. It will be a big surprise if Finn does not get the new ball instead of Rankin in the second innings and an even bigger one if he and Broad do not rip into the Australian top order to try to make a point or two ahead of the Test. Finn, in particular, knows that he has had an almost miraculous comeback, having looked the most likely of the tall quicks to be left out of the XII for Brisbane. A little fire in the second innings and his place will be safe for at least a couple of matches. However, the news is that Tim Bresnan will play either in Alice Springs or in the Development XI’s three day match and will, most likely, be available for selection for the 2nd Test so, unless he has a really good game at Brisbane, he may still lose his place later in the series.

Sunday, 10 November 2013

Lucky Generals


 

 

Ashes 2013

 

Dismissing England’s Challenge?

 

November 10th 2013

 

 

A post on a popular cricket website caught my attention. It pointed out that over the last two years, England had been “stuffed by Pakistan and South Africa and couldn’t even beat Sri Lanka and New Zealand away. Let’s move on”. As a put-down, it was pretty devastating and very dismissive. It reflects the oft-stated Australian “England are over-rated” school of thought. There is no doubt that England lost the spin war in the last Ashes. It is a matter of faith among Australian fans that Australia were robbed during the summer series. Far from being a matter of just two overs from losing 4-0, it was only rain and one-eyed umpiring that shopped them from winning the series. A lot of Australian supporters genuinely believe that they were the better team and the innocent victims of a heist last summer and that things will be set right at home.
For people who, like me, have followed England through thick and thin – an awful lot of thin in the ‘80s and ‘90s – for decades, the tour of the UAE was a horrible blip. Andy Flower has been as meticulous as Duncan Fletcher was until the pressures of the job and the loss of key players de-railed him. After years of getting used to good results, even with sides that, on paper looked inferior, England went to the UAE with a good side and seemed to under-estimate horribly the opposition. It set the side into a downward spiral: 3-0 defeat in the UAE; a comeback 1-1 draw in Sri Lanka; a 2-0 win at home against the West Indies (with the 3rd Test ruined by rain); followed by the series that really saw the wheels fall off the waggon where England lost 2-0 to South Africa. When England also lost the 1st Test in India most people feared the worst.

What followed was the small detail that our correspondent forgot. England came back to beat India 2-1 and not even the most enthusiastic Indian fan can say that India were not well beaten; Australia, in contrast, have lost their last 6 Tests in India and been whitewashed in both series. After losing 7 Tests from 12 over five series in 2012, England followed that up by winning in India, drawing in New Zealand, whitewashing New Zealand at home and then beating Australia 3-0: that is 7 wins in the next 12 Tests, with no defeats. It has seen England start to climb back up the ICC rankings to their current #2 position, just ahead of the revived Indians.
Australian fans will retort that England have been lucky. They could have lost the series in New Zealand. Rain intervened on the only two occasions that Australia passed 300 in the summer Test series, India fell apart when things started to do against them. England have been lucky but, it was Napoleon Bonapart who said:
 

“I know he's a good general, but is he lucky?”

No one can plan for luck to intervene in their favour, but you can certainly give luck a helping hand with adequate preparation. There is a famous phrase that is inaccurately attributed to the golfers Arnold Palmer and Gary Player, but which seems to be claimed by Lee Trevino:

Lee Trevino hit a magical iron shot, one that appeared to curve around a tree trunk, duck under branches, soar over a bunker and bite a few feet from the pin. “Signor Trevino,” called a Roman from the gallery, “are you always that lucky?” “Signor,” replied the U.S. Open champion, “the more I practice, the luckier I get.”

This though is an adaptation of a phrase that has been used at least since the 19th Century. It best summed up in the following quote from another golfer, Jerry Barber, in 1960, that sums up the Andy Flower philosophy.

The diminutive Los Angeles golfer sank a 15-foot putt on the second hole for birdie-3 and a 20-footer on the eight for a birdie-2.

“The harder you work the luckier you get,” said the 134-pound Barber

That, is Andy Flower!
There are times though when all the luck and preparation in the world cannot save you, which was what happened against South Africa. With the United Kingdom distracted by the magnificently successful London Olympics, Andy Flower had to deal with a dressing-room breakdown in the Kevin Pietersen affair and everything going wrong on the pitch. People tend to forget – or not even to know – that England had a first innings lead in two of the three Tests, so it was a far more competitive series than legend remembers.

In the 1st Test England’s very respectable 385 all out, with a century from Cook and fifties by Trott and Prior were blown away by Hasim Amla’s 311 not out and Dale Steyn’s 5-56. South Africa were simply in a different league. The 2nd Test though was a different kettle of fish: a big century and four wickets from Kevin Pietersen put England in what should have been a winning position on the last day and, had two vital catches not gone down, England would have had every chance of winning. When South Africa declared finally, England had been batted out of the game: 253 to win in 39 overs was just too many. South Africa had done what England had done so often in the last few years: ride their luck and make it count. The 3rd Test was yet another case. South Africa set 346 to win and, with England 45-4, it looked as if the match would finish quickly. England fought back and, at 282-7 on the last day, with Swann and Prior leading a glorious counter-attack, England were just 64 short and the South Africans were nearing panic. It took a run out to break the partnership and stop England from squaring the series.
South Africa showed how important it is to take advantage of your luck and won deservedly: one lucky General was beaten by one who was even luckier and who made his own luck!

However, even though Darren Lehmann is a very fine General, is he going to be a lucky one? One wonders if he has the troops to overcome an England side that also has a great General at the helm and that is trying to leave no stone unturned in the search for success in Australia. To a large degree you make your own luck and Andy Flower is trying to ensure that things go his way on the battlefield.

Saturday, 9 November 2013

England Enjoy Tasmania More Than Australia


 

 

Ashes 2013

 

Is your journey really necessary?

 

November 9th 2013

 

 

During the Second World War the British population were encouraged to save precious fuel with the slogan: “is your journey really necessary?” The England squad must be wondering if the slogan has been revived on recent Ashes tours. While the southeast of the country has been suffering drought and catastrophic bush fires, England have been rewarded with a trip to Tasmania. Tasmania is a place where one appreciates from the late spring temperature, that there is nothing between you and the South Pole. You also find that, even if you came to Australia expecting sun, rain is a fact of daily life in Van Diemen’s Land, along with winds blowing off Antarctica. The ACB’s careful preparations slipped when the Sun came out for the first day and England won the toss, but things returned to plan as, desperate to play on the fourth day, although with no hope of getting any kind of match from the wreckage, rain reduced the final day to two sessions.
Two sessions though were probably enough for England to finish happier than Australia. Joe Root scored a good fifty which will do little to quiet the speculation that he will do far better in the Tests at six than opening. Matthew Prior had a useful innings. And, although both failed – Kevin Pietersen to a genuinely unplayable ball – both he and Jonathon Trott at least got to the middle. Another selection issue was resolved by Gary Ballance falling cheaply again. With Jonny Bairstow not having played and Ballance’s two innings both being close to the shortest possible, England’s top nine for Brisbane are absolutely clear to all but a few die-hards: Cook, Carberry, Trott, Pietersen, Bell, Root, Prior, Broad and Swann. It is also absolutely clear that Ballance, Bairstow, Stokes, Finn, Rankin and Monty will all play at Alice Springs, this being possibly their last (and, in a couple of cases) only cricket of the tour and, as a two-day game, it will not even be First Class.

When Australia A finally batted, Jimmy Anderson showed that he is ready by action with two cheap wickets. Graeme Swann added Michael Klinger, who has terrorised Division Two bowlers in England this summer with a serious of superb performances for Gloucestershire and Chris Tremlett bowled eight tidy overs. None of the five Australia A batsmen who got to the middle passed 31, so none of them has made a pressing case for inclusion in Brisbane, which is hardly likely to cause Andrew Flower to shed a tear or two. Similarly, the news that yet another Australian fast bowler is out injured – this time Josh Hazlewood – and that Ben Cutting is one of the squad of quicks under consideration for Brisbane, will not cause too much lost sleep in Camp England. In fact, it can be argued that England have got far more out of this match than Australia, with the England side now picking itself, while Australia are still wondering who will be fit enough to get out onto the field.
The only concern was Stuart Broad, who needs plenty of middle time. Although he got more overs than anyone else, he was more expensive even than the overmatched Australia A bowlers and desperately needs more overs to get some rhythm. More rain in Sydney on Tuesday would be a disaster, but the situation is still under control at the moment.

Although there is an “if” and a “but” it looks as if Chris Tremlett may have sealed the third seamer spot for next week’s game and, hence, for Brisbane, although there are still real doubts whether the Chris Tremlett who struggled to hold a place in the Surrey side last summer, is still the Chris Tremlett of the 2010/11 Ashes series.

The England Tour Continues Going To Plan... For Australia




 


 


Ashes 2013


 

Smoke and mirrors

 

November 8th 2013

 

Ashes series are all about smoke and mirrors and this one looks to be no exception. Graham Gooch has just added another good blast of obscuring fog by commenting that far from being a deliberate plan to give Michael Carberry a chance to open in the Tests, it was all just an accident brought about by the happenstance of Alistair Cook dropping out of the Perth game with a sore back. One thing that England-watchers will have seen over the last few years is that such things are rarely left to chance, as the England cook book shows. In the absence of any play at Hobart and the absence of any real risk of play, the fact that England expect to receive a spinach curry instead of a chicken tikka masala has become a major talking point. The fact that Graham Gooch has revealed that he laments the lack of a good beef wellington has become a major talking point. It all goes to show that, in the absence of cricket, anything is good fare for the starving press.
The Australian media have delighted in the details of what the pampered darlings of the England side require on their dinner plates. What has not been mentioned is that, had the Australians shown the same sort of attention to detail, they would not have slipped so far down the ICC Test rankings that they depend on the West Indies losing badly in India to save them from the imminent indignity of dropping down to sixth in the ICC Test rankings.
Going into the Ashes series, South Africa continue in a comfortable lead in the rankings having limited the damage by squaring the series against Pakistan. England and India are in a tight battle for second and third, while another tight battle groups the mid-table sides, with Pakistan, Australia and the West Indies all within three points. Australia, still hanging on just above one hundred points, will drop below this benchmark if they lose the series by a margin of more than two Tests.
With the loss of a second full day the only thing that England can do, should play be possible in the final day, is to salvage what practice they can from the wreckage of the match. However, with the game reduced to a glorified net, the intensity is going to be low and trying to get something useful out of the game is going to be difficult. Australia can, even if they have learnt very little themselves, tick another day off on their fingers and smile, knowing that England have a maximum of just five days practice left before the 1st Test.

Thursday, 7 November 2013

The Best-Laid Plans...


 

 

Ashes 2013

 

Australia’s careful plan could misfire

 

November 7th 2013

 
 

With England sat pretty at 318-0 possibly the last thing that you wanted to see if you are an Australian is grey, murky skies over the Derwent River, with the prospect of England’s bowlers revelling in the sort of conditions that seam bowlers dream of. Before Kevin Pietersen has even batted on the tour, Australia have batted Carberry, Cook, Trott and Bell into form with comfortable centuries. In fact, none of them has even been dismissed after scoring a century as all four have been either “not out” or have retired. Unfortunately though for England, the murk and drizzle never lifted and a precious day of practice has been lost. Despite the early start planned for tonight, the forecast is for more of the same, which is not ideal.
Assuming that players can get on the field, it seems inconceivable that Cook and Carberry will not retire out overnight, leaving the only dismissal of one of England’s likely top five for the Tests as Carberry’s in the Perth match and even that for a healthy 70-odd. The issue is to get Pietersen, Root, Ballance and Prior some middle time before throwing the bowlers at Australia A.

The spin is that this has been a deliberately weak Australia A side, so that any England success with the bat is meaningless and of no concern to the Australians for the Ashes. How valid this is is open to some question. Trent Copeland has played 3 Tests and averages 24.5 in First Class cricket. Moises Henriques has played 3 Tests, 5 ODIs and 2 T20s. Ben Cutting has played 3 ODIs and 2 T20s and averages 24.9 in First Class cricket. Glenn Maxwell played in the Tests against India before the Ashes, bowling plenty of overs and has a lot of ODIs and T20s behind him. Even Jim Holland has 75 First Class wickets, albeit at a rather poor average, but that is a reflection more of the poverty of Australian spin bowling resources than of the poverty of selection (England supporters will recall the last two Ashes series for the succession of spinners, each more unlikely than the last, who were ranged against them before being summarily dropped). It is not a great Australia A side like some from the 1990s that were better than most other Test sides in the world, but you cannot expect a weak Test side with an injury crisis to have a powerful 2nd XI. The Australia A side is not as weak as it is painted.
One thing is certain and that is that the Australia A side has been picked to have powerful batting. This is just what the England bowlers need to prepare them: hard work on a flat pitch against proper batting will do none of them any harm. If that batting struggles, it will be interesting to see what spin is put on the performance after the events of Day 1.

Apart from the Carberry/Root issue, England have given some broad hints in this match about selection. This looks close to the final Test XI. Ballance will make way for Bell in the final match and Tremlett has been given the first chance to seal the third seamer spot, although there is still a chance that Boyd Rankin could nick it in the end: whichever plays next week will, barring disaster, play at Brisbane.
The losers in this are most definitely Jonny Bairstow and Monty Panesar. Neither have played so far and they are unlikely to play unless it is in the two-day game at Alice Springs between the 1st and 2nd Tests.  Steve Finn and Boyd Rankin, both of whom must have had high hopes of starting the Tests series as third seamer will also be wondering if they will play any more cricket on the tour apart from the Alice Springs game.

Wednesday, 6 November 2013

Australia Gamble On Lulling England Into A False Sense Of Security


 

 

Ashes 2013

 

Trick or treat?

 

November 6th 2013

 

 
Today marked the start of the serious preparation for the 1st Test in Brisbane, with a game against Australia A in Tasmania. England produced what was, at least to some, a major surprise by picking Michael Carberry, one of the big success stories of the Perth game, to open with Alistair Cook and dropping Joe Root to 5. On the fan fora the hint in the days before the game that maybe Joe Root might not be certain to open at Brisbane was pooh-poohed by most England supporters; it was even suggested that it would be a sign of panic. The suggestion was that, if you try something and it does not work out, you should persist with it stubbornly because, if you do not, you are guilty of panicking.

However, there were many hints that this was not a move that Andy Flower has come up with on a whim and a prayer. It was commented in India that there was no reserve opener: Compton and Cook were going to open the batting and, if one of them was injured, Plan B would be to use Jonathon Trott as an emergency opener. In a way it was a massive vote of confidence in Nick Compton to tell him that he would open for the whole series. For the Ashes tour though, not only did England pick a reserve opener, but they picked an experienced county pro who has toured with England, stepped in and played a Test and has been an England Lions regular, rather than someone such as Moin Ali who is an exciting young talent, but who has far less experience of top-level, pressure cricket. The obvious implication was that they wanted a seasoned professional who could step in and open in Tests with no fuss and no worries, rather than a young tyro who could struggle to make his mark in the tension of an Ashes series.

Andy Flower recognised two problems: England did not get good starts against Australia in the summer and, moving Joe Root from 6 had opened a hole in the middle order that Jonny Bairstow was struggling to fill. Joe Root is still only 22. He could reasonably play for England for 12 more years. He will learn and grow. No one would suggest that Michael Carberry is a long-term opener for England, but he offers the option of playing a series, maybe two series, shielding Joe Root from the new ball, which is the one area where Australia offer a real threat with the ball and taking some of the pressure off him. In this scenario, Joe Root would come back, possibly next winter, a more experienced and mature player, ready to lead the England batting for a decade or more. England would get better starts from a solid and unflappable opener and Joe Root would add his grit to the middle order: if it works, tell Australia to give up now.
This is one of those cases where the theory seems sound, but is usually followed by the batsman in question falling for a duck – end of experiment. With Cook and Carberry groping around for the ball early on and scoring at a snail’s pace from snicks and edges, it looked like a potential disaster but, as the morning wore on and the shine wore off the ball, the confidence came, runs started to flow more freely and the bowling looked as toothless as it had looked threatening an hour earlier. In these circumstances, you felt that the old England would get to 80-1, 100-2, 180-3 and that the day would be satisfactory, but mildly disappointing. However, this is not the old England. As the afternoon wore on the bowling wilted and the fielding looked lacklustre. You felt that if these were really the next eleven best players in Australia then the talent pool must be desperately thin. England got through a 93 over day without losing a wicket, with both openers passing 150. It will take a stunning turnaround now to deny Michael Carberry the chance to open the batting with Alistair Cook in Brisbane.

The spin was not long in coming. England were being suckered into easy runs against a two-man attack on a pitch as flat as a pancake and would fall apart when they faced proper bowling on a Brisbane minefield. However, a judge as clear-thinking as Jon Agnew suggested that Australia A were far from being as weak as was being suggested. Similarly, during the first hour of play the pitch certainly had not looked flat and dead, but the openers battled through it.
The Australian tactic seems to be similar to the Indian tactics last winter: provide pitches that look nothing like the Test tracks will do and weak bowling that is as far removed as possible from the Test attack. At the same time, take an England batting line-up that looked shaky and uncertain, play them into form and confidence and sort out their biggest uncertainty in the batting order. It may work, but it may also backfire horribly. Playing on sporty tracks in the Tests will help the Australian attack but, man for man in the summer series, the England attack was superior, so difficult pitches may not benefit Australia as much as they hope.

There is one further reason why the Australian tactics in this match may backfire. England batted on a glorious sunny day, quite unlike the normal conditions at the Bellerive Oval at Hobart. The forecast for Days 2 and 3 though is poor and Day 2 has dawned damp, overcast and threatening as expected. These are just the conditions where Broad, Anderson and Tremlett might be expected to enjoy themselves when England either declare, or get bowled out.
The first interesting question of the day though will be: will Carberry and Cook come back out to bat, or will they both retire out to allow Trott and Pietersen to bat, albeit in much less favourable conditions than yesterday?

Saturday, 2 November 2013

Time To Get Down To The Real Business



 

 

Ashes 2013

 

The serious business begins for both sides

 

November 2nd 2013

 
 

Today Australia’s tour of India ends and England’s first (and very gentle) warm-up in Perth has ended. From here things get more serious. It was traditional in past tours for England to play a scratch side in their first tour game and, almost as traditional for England to lose.
The Western Australia Chairman’s XI was a weak side and England picked what looked very much like a 2nd XI to play it, minus Monty Panesar, who was unwell and who would, most likely, have played. Billed as the battle of England’s tall fast bowlers, the pitch made the ones on offer in Bangladesh’s recent series against New Zealand look lively. It is hard to avoid the impression that the Australians are keen to avoid England getting any kind of useful practice. This has led to a cross-fire of allegations with the Australians saying that fair is fair as the ECB refused to give them any meaningful practice in England last summer.

In part this is a reflection of the change in the England set-up. Long gone is the time when county players queued up to play against touring sides knowing that a century or a five wicket haul would give them a real chance of playing in the next Test. These days, with a much more stable (and successful) England side, only a long period of sustained county form, backed up by success with the Lions is likely to get one of those coveted Test places.
Counties now see matches against the tourists as a chance to rest star players and try out some youngsters. It leads to an overall impression that this is a deliberate policy to stymie the tourists and invites revenge, although India’s last winter was extreme by any standards, picking seam-heavy attacks on very un-Indian surfaces. Over the last couple of seasons the inevitable result have been that the ECB has requested that counties guest players to provide practice for players on the fringes of the Test side and more realistic opposition for the tourists (Andrew Strauss for Somerset, two seasons ago; last summer Nick Compton for Worcestershire, James Taylor for Sussex).

One of the Australian complaints voiced on fan fora and alluded to by the ACB, was that they were only given matches against weak Division 2 opposition and this is justification to give England similarly poor opposition. In fact, this is not a claim that stands up to any kind of scrutiny. Australia played Somerset (Division 1 runners-up the previous season) and Sussex (who ended up challenging for the Championship for most of the season), plus the just-relegated Worcestershire, strengthened with the inclusion of Nick Compton. They also had a game against a strong England Lions side. It is hard to sustain the allegation that a side with a top five containing Trescothick, Compton, Hildreth and Kieswetter was cherry-picked to be weak! The odd man out in that top five, Chris Jones, scored a magnificent 130 against Starc, Pattinson, Siddle, Faulkner and Lyon. Only two of the Somerset side were not 1st XI regulars and that was more down to the Somerset injury crisis than any particular conspiracy. Often fans do not realise that tour schedules are pacted with the visiting Board and have to be accepted by both sides, hence England requested – and received – three matches against 1st Class opposition on their tour.
In fact, over the summer tour, Australia played 6 ODIs (two unofficial), plus two four day matches before the 1st Test: 14 days of cricket, although the ODI against New Zealand was rained-off (not the ECB’s fault). At the same time, the Australia A side, containing several Test players who were not needed for the Champions Trophy, played three-day matches against Scotland and Gloucestershire (in this latter game they came extremely close to losing against the side that had finished bottom of the County Championship the previous season), plus an unofficial Test against the full Ireland side, while other members of the Test side had their regular county contracts and were playing Division 1 cricket. It is hard to sustain the argument that there was a deliberate effort to make sure that Australia had no proper practice: in fact, England are the only country that regularly gives visiting tourists county contracts to play and acclimatise before a tour starts, before releasing the players to their Test side. It all makes the standard “whinging poms” line sound rather ironic.

That though, is by the by. Neither Australia nor England should feel too delighted today. While Bell and Trott both scored first innings centuries and Carberry – deputising for Alistair Cook and his bad back – scored an excellent 78, that was about the end of the good news. Joe Root 36 was the only other England score over Steve Finn’s 15 and the sceptics who say that his technique is being found out by opening will have more ammunition. Carberry’s form though offers England the option of opening with him and Cook and dropping Joe Root back down to #6 where he has done so well. Balance, Prior and Stokes summed just eight runs between them. With Stokes adding 1-56 and 0-18 with the ball, it is quite possible that he will see no more cricket in the middle until the ODIs start. Not that any of the other members of the attack did much better: Boyd Rankin’s 1-92 and 2-34 were, by far, the stand-out bowling performance by England, with Jimmy Anderson not bowling at all in the second innings after an impressively accurate start. However, with England playing Anderson, Broad and Swann together, plus one of the tall seamers, things might look rather different. Certainly, with Cook and KP also to come in for the second match, the England side will look very different.
Lest Australia start to crow, their day has not been exceptional either. While Australia have won two matches on their tour of India, having not won an international match on their previous two, they have lost the T20 series and the ODI series and, apart from the 1st ODI where India folded for 232, conceded scores of: 202-4 in the T20, 362-1, 303-9, 351-4 and, today, 383-6. With the Test attack suffering from an injury plague, bowlers such as Mitch Johnson, Clint McKay and Glenn Maxwell are very serious options for the Brisbane Test. Although Mitch Johnson had a fine series and has made himself a prime contender for the Test series, his 7 wickets in the series at under 6 an over are very much padded by his 4-46 in the second game. Faulkner’s 7 wickets came at almost 47 each and at 7.2 an over. McKay’s 4 wickets cost an eye-watering 75 each and Shane Watson’s 3, 76 each. Once Mitch Johnson was out of the attack, the Indian batsmen were left more or less free to score at will.