Showing posts with label Ben Stokes. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Ben Stokes. Show all posts

Monday, 26 August 2019

England v Australia: Third Test, Stokes Re-Kindles the Ashes as Australia Throw it Away


 

England v Australia: Third Test

Stokes Re-Kindles the Ashes as Australia Throw it Away

August 25th 2019

 

England should now be 2-0 down with two to play and the destination of the Ashes, but not the series, decided. They are not, thanks to a series of extraordinary events that highlights the fragility of both sides.

An Australian collapse at Lord’s threatened to give England an unexpected chance to square the series after the heavy defeat at Edgbaston. That England were blown away in the 1st Test, having dominated the match for the first three days, was a salutary lesson. Australia were fifteen behind with their top three dismissed, but England could not finish them off. Might it have changed the result if Jimmy Anderson had not hobbled off after bowling just four overs on the first morning? Just possibly, but a side should be able to overcome such handicaps. Would England have won the 2nd Test had they not lost an hour on the final morning after so much play – effectively, two full days – had not been lost previously? Quite possibly! These though are simple imponderables: we do not know what would have happened and, both times, Australia rode their luck and battled through.

With Steve Smith, previously the difference between the two sides, out of the 3rd Test, England had their Ashes 2005 moment. In that series, the freak injury to Glenn McGrath, when he trod on a cricket ball in the warm-up, changed the destination of the series. England revived. Steve Smith out. Jofra Archer causing mayhem. The momentum swinging, surely England had to win now, or lose the series?

Even more, Australia blinked first with selection. Apart from the enforced change to replace Steve Smith, with Labuschagne proving every bit as effective a stand-in as Jofra Archer was for Jimmy Anderson, Cameron Bancroft was the fall-guy for top-order failings. The change made no difference, with Australia 25-2 within forty minutes, but then it was England who lost the plot. An hour of buffet bowling and Australia were in a strong position when they could have been all out for under 100. Take away the 111 stand between a revived Warner and Labuschagne and twenty wickets fell for 145 between the first two innings of the match and the start of the third. For all the complaints that Chris Woakes has been underbowled, his arthritic performance on the first afternoon as two batsmen scored almost as many as the other twenty in the first innings, suggests that his knee is troubling him more than is being admitted. In conditions in which you would have expected him to make hay, his match figures were 25-5-85-2.

The less said about England’s first innings, the better. Jason Roy’s fourth consecutive single-figure score and the manner of his dismissals, show that he is not making a success of opening the innings. Against Australia, he has a sequence of 10, 28, 0, 2, 9 & 8. Joe Root is playing out of position to protect lesser batsmen around him and struggling. Root plays all three formats and has been flogged into the ground over the last couple of years, a fact that some of the more ungrateful fans who are calling for his head, forget conveniently. And Joe Denly is managing a positively James Vince-like sequence of getting a start and then failing to pass thirty. Below them, Bairstow and Buttler look a shadow of the counter-attacking players who can win a Test in session. The Australians were given good bowling conditions to use against a frail line-up and proved irresistible.

Australia, though, are not much better off. Their top order is no more solid than England’s and the middle order is struggling. There is speculation that Tim Paine may have to drop himself because he cannot buy a run and Matt Wade desperately needs a score. The Australia of Allan Border or Steve Waugh would have taken that first innings lead of 112 and sailed off into the distance. At 215-6, with the England attack struggling, they had a chance to push past 400 lead and kill the game but, just as England had failed to apply the killer blow at Edgbaston, Australia were not good enough to apply it here.

A better side than Australia would have taken their chances. When both openers fall to the new ball in under half an hour, with the opposition facing attaining the tenth highest fourth innings chase if they were to keep the Ashes alive and with the batsmen playing as if facing hand grenades, blindfold, with a moral victory for the bowlers at least once an over, the killer blow should have fallen. Yet it did not.

The lesson is that this is a series between two mediocre, inconsistent sides, both capable of moments of brilliance… and a lot of dross.

The key aspect of the partnership between Root and Denly was not the number of runs scored, but the fact that it gave their side belief that the match could be won. It also started to sow the seeds of doubt in Australian minds: a doubt that must have contributed to the frazzled state twenty-four hours later. Even when Joe Root fell early on the fourth morning, just before the new ball, rather than signalling the end, as the fielding side must have expected, the arrival of the new ball brought a flood of runs, as the previously stroke-less Stokes and the previously run-less, Bairstow, combined to reduce the number of runs required ever-closer to the hundred mark that was within reach of a single partnership.

No one can legislate for a batsman chancing his arm and it coming off. In 1981, Ian Botham did it, memorably, both at Headingly and at Old Trafford. These things happen. But you can make it easier for the batsman. Stokes should have been out early in his innings: the chance went begging.

Australian fans will, however, forever believe that they were cheated of victory. Ben Stokes should have been given LBW with 2 runs needed to win, but Joel Wilson gave him the benefit of someone’s doubt. Australia would have won by one run – shades of the Border/Thompson stand in the 1982/83 Ashes – but it should have never got to that. Australia totally lost the plot.

When David Warner dropped Stokes on 34 in the morning session, it did not look so costly. With 17 needed to win, Marcus Harris, who has had a pretty forgettable match, missed a more difficult chance. Then Jack Leach committed suicide, charging down the wicket and should have been run out by yards, but Nathan Lyon dropped the ball and Leach scrambled back. That was symptomatic of scrambled minds that were making mistakes under pressure. A lot of that pressure was being applied by a crowd that never stopped believing and cheered to the echo every four, every six, every single and every forward defensive.

How else do you account for the way that, over after over, Stokes was allowed a comfortable single from the fifth or sixth ball? Australia never pinned him down at one end so that they could attack at the other. How else do you account for the fact that even when they had Leach in their sights, the bowlers could not produce the match-winning delivery? Leach never even looked uncomfortable. How else can you explain the way that none of the bowlers managed to deliver a single Yorker in the block-hole to either Stokes, who was swinging away and thus vulnerable to one, or to Leach? Supposedly, limited-overs cricket as taught bowlers the knack of bowling that lethal, block-hole delivery at the death, but that skill went missing during the frenetic, frantic, last wicket partnership. Or that when Leach was facing early in what proved to be the final over, he was allowed to nudge the single that got him off the mark and levelled the scores?

And, Australia would have won had they not wasted already their review on a quite desperate attempt to remove Jack Leach. When they actually needed a review, six balls later, they had none left.

The English, being the English, will feel guilt that victory was tainted by an umpiring error. Many Australian fans will feed that sense of guilt and make out that they were cheated. Had the roles been reversed, the Australians would have just said “tough mate! You should have taken your chances.” You make your own luck and Australia deserved no better.

The truth of the matter is that, when put under pressure, the Australians cracked. The match should never have been allowed to depend at the very last moment on an umpire who was under extreme pressure too, a good part of it due to the fielding side appealing for everything; it should have been settled long before then.

Ben Stokes’ innings was extraordinary, as was his calmness and awareness, but no less extraordinary was Jack Leach’s calm under extreme pressure, with half the Australian side close enough to touch him and chatting away. Most #11s would have thrown it away: Leach did not.

The 1st Test was won by an extraordinary batting performance by Steve Smith and the 2nd Test saved thanks in great measure to another. The 3rd was won by an extraordinary batting performance by Ben Stokes. With the bowlers holding sway, the series will be decided by which of the two sides manages to produce such innings more often.

Both sides have chronic problems. The top three of both teams has the solidity of wet tissue paper. With a week and a half between Tests, there is time to reflect and take decisions after mature reflection. While Rory Burns has earned himself the full series, the time has come to end the experiment with Jason Roy: he may ride his luck and make a score in the series, but he does not suggest permanence. Similarly, time is running out for Joe Denly. He has reached double figures in every Test this summer, yet passed 30 just once. And Joe Root must drop back down to #4.

England already have a perfect excuse to make changes. Assuming that Jimmy Anderson has shown no reaction to his 2nd XI outing and is considered fit, he will enter the side at his home ground. It could be that he replaces a bowler – presumably, Chris Woakes – but there is also the possibility that he could replace a batsman and that Sam Curran could replace Chris Woakes. People will look to the heavens at that suggestion but, with the form of some of the batsmen, the depth of the batting will hardly be weakened, but there will be an extra bowling option to keep control. Or England could take the opportunity to refresh both batting and bowling without it looking like panic.

One batting solution would be to bring in Dom Sibley. A look at Sibley’s numbers this season shows that he has not only scored huge numbers of runs, but his strike rate in the low 40s shows that he has had a lot of patience and is willing to grind out an innings. This is just what England need at the top of the order. Sibley, though, had a double failure against Somerset in his only First Class outing since mid-July and will not get another innings before the 4th Test. Sibley may regret that he timed his one, poor match of the season badly. The ECB should regret the ludicrous scheduling of the feeder competition for the Test side.

An indicator of selectorial thinking is that Ollie Pope was called-up as cover for Jason Roy, after Roy’s blow to the head in the nets, making it far more likely that, at least at Old Trafford, Pope will play instead of Sibley. Doing this allows too a re-jig of the top order. There is a case for Joe Denly to be asked to open with Burns at Old Trafford, with Ollie Pope at #3 and Joe Root at #4. This is a risky solution as, despite his unbeaten double century, Pope has, apart from that single innings, played only T20 since his early season injury and Denly’s experience as an opener is mainly limited to ODIs and T20s for England, ten years ago. However, Denly seems far more likely and prepared to see off the new ball than is Jason Roy: one thing that he has been doing is to stick around, even if the runs have not accompanied. If the coach says to him, “Joe, we are happy to see you bat out a full session for 20”, he is the one player in the top 4 who you can see capable of doing it and of relishing the challenge.

At the same time, Australia will make further changes. The bowlers have been rotated and will continue to rotate. Space will be made for Steve Smith, unless his outing against Derbyshire is a disaster. Marnus Labuschagne will keep his place. David Warner’s innings has probably saved his place, but Matt Wade and Tim Paine’s places are certainly under threat. It is far from impossible that Australia could make as many as three or even four changes.

Both sides will go to Old Trafford thinking of what might have been. England know that they let slip a big first innings lead at Edgbaston and, with a little more luck in the 2nd Test, could now be 3-0 up. Australia will know that they dodged the bullet in the 2nd Test and were the better side for most of the game at Headingly and should be 2-0 up and retaining the Ashes. With their talisman back, Australia will expect to put things to rights at Old Trafford. However, if yesterday was a flashback to Headingly ’81, Australia would be wise to recall that Ian Botham produced another extraordinary match-winning innings in a crisis at Old Trafford later that same summer.

Bottom line: expect the unexpected. Both sides are capable of great things… and of producing dross.

Wednesday, 23 January 2019

West Indies v England, 1st Test, Day 1: Anderson and Stokes Provoke a Calypso Collapso


 

West Indies v England

1st Test, Day 1: Anderson and Stokes Provoke a Calypso Collapso

January 23rd 2019

 With the pitch suggesting to Joe Root that a second spinner might be more useful than an extra seamer, Sam Curran put another nail in the incipient coffin of Stuart Broad’s Test career by keeping him out of the side again and Adil Rashid won the battle for the #10 spot in the batting order from Jack Leach, with the selectors reasoning that his ability to produce an explosive, wicket-taking delivery was more important than Leach’s economy and ability to close-down an end. While the Curran-for-Broad selection worked in Sri Lanka, where seamers were bit-players, how effective it will be in the Caribbean is open to doubt. Broad, at his best, is by far the better bowler, although Curran offers variety, giving a left-arm/right-arm opening attack, something that England have missed for many years. However, it did not take long for doubts to surface, with his first ball disappearing to the boundary and the 21 runs from his first five overs providing sharp contrast to the just 4 runs from Jimmy Anderson’s first five. The decision to play Adil Rashid brought the normal storm of protest on social media, ignoring the fact that the eight matches since his unexpected recall have brought him 22 wickets at 29.4, well below his career average and a reputation for making critical breakthroughs when most needed and least expected. While the Moeen-Leach OB/SLA combination is probably the best match and the most reliable, life is never boring when Adil Rashid is bowling. And to think that Dominic Bess, who made such a favourable impression last summer, is no better than fourth choice and maybe even fifth. Spin may be dead, but England have probably six spinners right now who are as good as any who played in the barren years before Monty Panesar’s brief career.

Within an hour in the morning the fans more inclined to knee-jerk reactions were summing-up the match and the series. As Jimmy Anderson reeled-off maiden after maiden at one end, Sam Curran’s first ball sailed away to the boundary. Things did not get much better for him after that inauspicious start. Suffice it to say that he does not look like a new ball bowler at this level.The pitch looked friendly. The bowling looked impotent. And the selection of Curran and Adil Rashid ahead of Broad and Leach looked like a pretty crass error. It was a situation that threatened 300-3 at the Close and a hard day chasing leather. The openers put on 53 and then 73 were added for the second wicket. At 126-1, with only Jimmy Anderson exercising any control, Stuart Broad was beginning to look like a bowler of legendary powers (it is curious, when he is in the side the fans moan that he has done nothing to justify his place and, when he not picked, they moan that he is the best bowler that we have). There was though a little warning of the frailties of Caribbean cricket as Ben Stokes picked up Brathwaite and Bravo in quick succession and 126-1 became a slightly less solid 128-3. Still, five of the top six reached 40 and with the new ball taken and the Close looming, 240-4 looked like the foundation for 400+. The West Indians just needed someone to hang around and turn a solid start into a big score and make England suffer. This is not a great England side, but one of its virtues is that it finds ways to turn games that look to be heading the way of the opposition.

Sixteen deliveries with the new ball and even though the odd ball beat the bat, more were beating the boundary fielders. Then Royston Chase played a loose shot and, suddenly, the batting disintegrated in the Calypso Collapso fashion that has encouraged tired bowlers for years. Three quick wickets for Jimmy Anderson and then one for Ben Stokes with what proved to be the last ball of the day. The West Indians can consider themselves fortunate that, despite a decent over-rate from England, the umpires considered that there was not enough time left to finish the over, otherwise you would not have bet against a ninth wicket falling.

264-8 represented a decent day’s work yet, with the new ball suddenly starting to spit and misbehave, you wonder if the pitch really is as benign as it appeared to be in the morning. It could have been even better. At 178-4, Hetmayer drove Jimmy Anderson to Jos Buttler at cover. Buttler shelled what should have been a fairly straightforward catch and Hetmayer went on to 56* at the Close. Maybe England will pay for two sessions of anaemic cricket and 280 will prove to be a match-winning score: that you never know until both sides have batted and, sometimes, not even then. England though have a got themselves into a position that offers them a real chance if they can finish the tail quickly in the morning. With Jimmy Anderson resting on figures of 24-12-33-4 and Ben Stokes, 19.2-2-47-3, with a still new ball in the morning, the England batsmen may get their chance quite quickly.

Monday, 26 November 2018

Sri Lanka v England, 3rd Test Day 4: Tea Kills Sri Lankan Hopes of a Miracle


 

Sri Lanka v England

3rd Test Day 4: Tea Kills Sri Lankan Hopes of a Miracle

November 26th 2018

 

There have only been 8 successful fourth innings chases at the SSC, while twelve times, including today, the chase has ended in defeat. The highest successful chases are:

·       326-5: Sri Lanka v Zimbabwe, 1988

·       172-4: Sri Lanka v West Indies, 2005

·       142-5: Sri Lanka v England, 1993

·       131-5: Pakistan v Sri Lanka, 2000

·       74-6: England v Sri Lanka, 2001.

For a significant part of the afternoon session, Sri Lankan fans started to dream of pulling-off an incredible heist. Had Tea come half an hour later, it is possible that Sri Lanka would have won, given how Lakmal and Pushpakumara had added 58 in 12 overs and were grinding-down the bowling to helplessness with a mixture of solid defence and hard swinging.

The deficit at Tea was 43 and horrible thoughts were rising in the backs of the minds of the visiting fans, as the home fans started to wonder if they were going to see a historic turnaround. Numerous times though a significant Sri Lankan partnership has broken just after Tea, changing the momentum of a match: what Joe Root could not obtain with a bowling change, he invariably managed with a cup of Ceylon tea – rival to Darjeeling as the best cuppa in the world and, in this series, a lethal wicket-taker. While Pushpakumara was swinging merrily, they were distracted from the nerves that come with knowing that a target, previously out of reach, was almost within touching distance. A tenth wicket partnership can be gloriously uninhibited when it knows that victory is impossible. Had Tea come with fewer than 20 wanted to win, you can imagine that the nerves would have been transferred to the fielding side and that Sri Lanka would have been, perhaps, the favourites. As it was, the batsmen trooped back to the pavilion just before the fielding side reached a state of total disarray.

The result was almost inevitable. You felt that the first two overs after the interval would be the danger: if the batsmen got through them, they might yet knock off the runs; if they survived five overs after Tea, panic might set in to the fielding side, but that those first two overs might well be decisive.

Fourth ball after Tea, Lakmal got a ball that straightened just enough to hit the stumps. Before Tea, most likely he would have dealt with it. After Tea, the instincts and the concentration were dulled just enough for the ball to miss Lakmal’s prod. Jack Leach had the last wicket of the series, sealed the 0-3 win and, to boot, equalled Moeen Ali’s tally of wickets for the series and ensured that even though Ben Stokes topped the bowling averages for the series, he would pip Perera, Moeen and Sandakan to top the averages for spin bowlers.

England had made heavy weather of finishing off a spirited opposition. As predicted last night, the biorhythms were off in the morning, the nightwatchman did hang around and the momentum was lost, with a substantial sixth wicket partnership threatening to bring Sri Lanka back into the match. As though has been the Sri Lankan wont throughout the series, just when their batsmen were getting on top, they threw it away. The stand was at 102. Mendis was approaching a century. And a senseless runout stopped both Mendis and the partnership. There were 22, fifties in the series – 11 by England, 11 by Sri Lanka – yet the only four centuries were scored by Englishmen. No England batsman was dismissed between 64 and 107, but six Sri Lankan batsmen were. Adil Rashid bowled a googly. Roshen Silva pushed it away and set off for two. Leach fielded and threw, right-handed, with lethal precision at the non-striker’s end and an end was opened. A flat England side were re-invigorated and Moeen and Leach shared the last four wickets: the first two to catches to Keaton Jennings, who took six in the match, eight in the series and, surprisingly, was pipped to the title of leading catcher, not by either of the wicket-keepers, but by Ben Stokes, with 9[1]. Jennings only went to the Short Leg position after Rory Burns took a sickening blow there: you wonder how many catches he might have had in the series if he had fielded there for all three Tests.

Much has been made of the retirement of Herath for Sri Lanka, but this is largely a red herring as he has not for the last couple of years wanted to play even a full 3-match series. While he played both Tests at home against South Africa, he played just one in the shared series in the Caribbean. The overall impression was of two limited sides, with England always just a little too good for their opponents, particularly at the critical moments. Sri Lanka though are nowhere near as poor as some of the apologists have claimed: you do not beat South Africa 2-0 with a poor team and, in that series, all five Sri Lankan bowlers, all of whom also played against England too, averaged under 17.3 with the ball. Against bowlers who had been devastating against South Africa, England found a method that worked so well that the same bowlers took their wickets at triple the cost.

It is not a brilliant England side. There are too many manifest weaknesses for that, but it has the makings of a pretty good one if it can consolidate in the New Year in the Caribbean.  

 



[1] 8 caught and 2 stumped for Ben Foakes. 7 caught and 1 stumped for Dickwella.

Saturday, 24 November 2018

Sri Lanka v England, 3rd Test Day 2: Two Sessions of Total Sri Lankan Dominance Before Surrender


 

Sri Lanka v England

3rd Test Day 2: Two Sessions of Total Sri Lankan Dominance Before Surrender

November 24th 2018

 

Can this series get any odder? Sri Lanka totally dominated the first two sessions of play and looked set to punish a sloppy England and set up an utterly invincible position when, somehow, after Tea, they found a way to hand the initiative straight back.

173-1, twenty-two balls before Tea, Karunaratne and De Silva were both sailing through the 70s. Both looked set for a century and England looked utterly devoid of ideas. Joe Root had dropped two catches – both, of course, off Stuart Broad – and had cost England some way north of one hundred runs already. It looked set for a difficult post-Tea session with an old ball that was doing precisely nothing. Moeen had been flogged out of the attack. Stuart Broad had retired to the outfield after a second, luckless spell, presumably to be as far from his captain as possible. And, after a long spell, Jack Leach was being picked-off, without threatening to take a wicket on the best batting pitch of the series.

Where is Ben Stokes (just a single over in the 2nd Test)? Where is Adil Rashid, the fans asked? Finally, they came on in tandem and, after a long spell when the scoring was accelerating and the match was drifting away, suddenly things happened. Stokes had an LBW shout that was turned down, but was umpire’s call. Adil Rashid bowled a ball full. De Silva turned it to leg. And Keaton Jennings swooped. Whatever his problems in the slips last summer, Jennings is not missing a thing under the helmet.

While both Stokes and Adil Rashid can have the control of a paint spray, both are able to make things happen. While Stokes roughed the batsmen up – an achievement on a pitch that offered him absolutely nothing – the odd ball started to turn prodigiously. Karunaratne got one in the ribs just before Tea, which ensured that there would not be an extra over before the break. That will have allowed time for the blow to get cold and may explain why, straight after Tea, Karunaratne played outside a googly that turned beautifully, edged on the pad and straight to Jennings when a century appeared his for the taking. Two new batsmen at the crease and Sri Lanka fell apart. There was a period of four overs at 205-5 when a wicket did not fall but then four fell in three overs as Ben Stokes and Adil Rashid gave the batsmen the holy terrors.

Apart from the first wicket, that had fallen to Leach, the other nine all involved combinations of Jennings, Foakes, Stokes and Adil Rashid. If Jennings did not catch it with cat-like reflexes, Foakes did and when neither was involved, it was Adil Rashid with a dead-eyed throw to produce a run-out off the bowling of Stokes.

240ao represented a barely believable collapse. After the highest partnership of the series – a small matter of 142 between Karunaratne and De Silva – the highest partnership for the last eight wickets was just 14. After two sessions in which the last three wickets surrendered cheaply and tamely and then the Sri Lankan batsmen made merry, with England far below the level of the first two Tests, the match had been turned on its head. From facing a potential large deficit, England had a totally unexpected 96-run lead, extended to 99 before bad light intervened.

Best-ever Test figures for Adil Rashid. Four catches for Keaton Jennings – one short of Yajuvendra Singh’s Test record. Three wickets for Ben Stokes, in a series in which seamers have been passengers. And after three very poor sessions, one good session was all England needed to set up a potential 0-3 whitewash.

A bizarre series has taken another very odd turn.

Quite apart from the victory in the Test, there is plenty for England to play for. Burns and Jennings both need a score to seal their places. Jonny Bairstow will be keen to add more runs at #3. Moeen would like some runs too. And the bowlers will need a score to defend in the fourth innings. And, poor Stuart Broad will hope that someone does take a catch off his bowling, should he manage to induce one.       

Wednesday, 23 May 2018

England v Pakistan: 1st Test Preview - And the Winner is… Dom Bess!


 

England v Pakistan: 1st Test Preview

And the Winner is… Dom Bess!

May 23rd 2018

First: an apology… I never did wrap up the New Zealand series. Disappointment at the outcome – when you take wickets with the first two balls of the day and it is all downhill from there, it takes some effort to dredge up the effort to write. New Zealand held out comfortably for the draw and took the series. England were not good enough. New Zealand were good value for their win and deserved it thoroughly.

Then, a heavy schedule at work was followed by being signed-up by the View from the Outfield website to report on County cricket – if you don’t know View from the Outfield, you can find it at viewfromtheoutfield.com: it is well worth a read – which is taking two or three hours out of many of my evenings.

Another season, another series. Pakistan are the warm-up act for the summer’s main series against India, with an ODI series against Australia sandwiched in between. For England, this summer bears a depressing similarity to 2014, when England played after a 5-0 defeat in Australia, then lost for the first time at home to Sri Lanka and were being thoroughly outplayed by India before Moeen Ali went from being “Moeen Who??” to being “the beard that is feared”.

There is an irony in the fact that, having been a fixture in the England side for four years since his Lord’s debut against Sri Lanka in 2014, Moeen was almost certainly not even mentioned by the selectors for this Test. In India and Australia over the last two winters, England have given debuts to Liam Dawson, Zafir Ansari, Mason Crane and Jack Leach. Ansari has retired. Liam Dawson’s star has faded to the extent that he is unlikely to play another Test. Crane is just coming back from serious injury and now it is the turn of Jack Leach, who took Mason Crane’s place in New Zealand when Crane was injured, to have a serious injury himself.

While short-sighted curmudgeons have been moaning about playing on “the beach at Taunton”, England are seeing it pay dividends. Jack Leach was one of the few successes on the Lion’s tour to the Caribbean and his spin-twin, Dom Bess, also came out of that tour with great credit with a maiden century (in the post-Lions, Champion county match) and wickets. He may have played only sixteen First Class matches and he may not be a regular in the Somerset side but, when he plays, he has often been lethal. Twenty years old and averaging four wickets per match in his short career, astute followers of the county game have known for a year that his Test match debut was just a matter of time: most people expected to be against Sri Lanka in the Autumn but, the attrition rate of spinners means that he will get an early chance to impress. Lest we forget, Alf Valentine had only played TWO First Class matches before he set about destroying the England batting in 1950.

It could all end in tears – England have tried spinner after spinner since the decline and fall of Swann and Monty – but remember that Nathan Lyon was the thirteenth spinner to be tried by Australia in a short space of time and he seems to have done okay.  There are plenty of cricketing reasons to believe that, come this Autumn, in Leach and Bess, England will take to Sri Lanka their most potent spin combination since 2011.

Do not expect miracles from Dom Bess. He has taken just one wicket so far this season on the seam-friendly pitches, as Somerset have relied so far on pace, but this game will be about his temperament and readiness. Bess will play, as England have already stated that he will provide the variety in a seam-heavy attack.

For England there are many questions:

·       Has Alistair Cook still got the hunger to score big runs? In 2017 he was scoring runs for fun for Essex before the Tests. In 2018, he has managed 84, 0, 26, 37 and 66. After a pretty dreadful winter, there is enough there to show that he is getting some form back but, will it last into the Pakistan Tests?

·       Mark Stoneman is lucky to hold his place. He scored 4x50 during the winter and bettered his best Test score three times, falling in single-figures just twice in seven Tests, but still has not passed 60. Can he make a definitive contribution and seal his place? He has reached 20 four times in seven innings this season for Surrey, but has yet to reach 30. In contrast, Keaton Jennings is on a run of 109, 126, 136, 73 and 69 for Lancashire. If Jennings can maintain this prolific form, it will be hard to ignore him.

·       What about Joe Root at #3? He prefers to bat at 4. It is well-chronicled that it is a long time since Root has converted a 50 into a century: he has been scoring 50s a-plenty, but the difference between the two sides in Australia was often the relative contributions of the captains. Can Root score big runs at #3 and improve his conversion statistics?

·       Is Ben Stokes ready for Tests again? We already know that he will miss one of the Tests against India as his charge for affray will come up in Bristol Crown Court, where he faces a possible sentence of three years in prison. How distracted is he by what is coming up and by the media circus that will follow him?

·       What about Jos Buttler? He will bat at 7 with a licence to play with freedom. However, he played just one red-ball game in 2017 and has struggled to adapt to Tests. Can he harness his incredible talents in Tests? His form, opening, in the IPL has been extraordinary, but that is a very different problem to batting in a Test.

·       Which way will England jump with the fourth seamer: Chris Woakes or Mark Wood? Woakes was bitterly disappointing in Australia and Mark Wood can hardly say that he seized his opportunity in New Zealand with both hands. Can either cut it long-term at Test level?

·       And, the $64000 question: how long have Stuart Broad and Jimmy Anderson got left? Anderson was masterful in Australia and Stuart Broad looks to be back to his best, but England know that Anderson is on borrowed time and Broad may have only two years left in him at this level, even if his form continues to justify his place.

Last time Pakistan toured England, they shared the series, celebrated wins with press-ups. They also became #1 in the ICC Test rankings to boot. Now they are #7 having barely won a match since. They beat Ireland, but not after Tim Murtagh and Kevin O’Brien gave them an almighty scare (in the end they were relieved to scramble over the line) and have been depressingly badly treated with the warm-ups, by having games against the hapless Northants and a weak Leicestershire: as preparation goes for a Test series the ECB should be embarrassed and ashamed by their lack of generosity as hosts.

It is quite likely that just four of the eleven players who faced England at Lord’s less than two years ago will be in the Pakistan XI. Like England, they desperately need a strong showing for their own credibility. Pakistan are mercurial: perhaps the most naturally talented cricketers in the world, they get too easily distracted by what they see as on and off-the-field conspiracies and, as a result, disintegrate far too easily. Just as England have to learn to cope with pitches taking big turn in India and the UAE, India and Pakistan have to learn to cope with a tinge of green in the pitch in England without screaming “foul!!” Cricket is intended to be played on grass and, in a wet and humid country, grass tends to grow green.

The bad news for England is that even a 2-0 series win – which seems to be totally implausible – will barely gain any ranking points: England need to win 1-0 even to stand still. Pakistan will remember what Sri Lanka did in 2014 and know that England are vulnerable and that there are questions against the name of almost every player in the XI; the Pakistanis will be only too happy to deepen the England crisis and are quite capable of doing it if they can retain their focus.

Wednesday, 28 March 2018

New Zealand v England: 1st Test, Day 5 - Defeat, in a Match that Could and Should Have Been Saved


 

New Zealand v England: 1st Test, Day 5

Defeat, in a Match that Could and Should Have Been Saved

March 28th 2018

When you are 300-6 with about 30 overs left and have two, well-set batsmen, one on 66*, the other, 38*, the partnership nearing 100, the ball is no longer new and there is significant batting still to come, you would normally believe that the batting side has a very good chance of saving the match. Once again the culprit was a silly shot on the stroke of a break. Once Stokes gave his wicket away, the end was mercifully quick and 300-6 became 320ao. Yet again, there was a feeling of what might have been.

However, all the familiar failings were there. Four batsmen scored fifties, but three of them fell immediately on reaching fifty (scores of 55, 51 and 52) and the fourth fell for 66: no one could go on to on to a big score. Two of the batsmen who made a fifty fell to the last ball before an interval. Apart from Cook, no one earlier than 9 in the batting order fell for fewer than 23 – so everyone got a start – but no one went on to make the sort of score that would have saved the match. It was a matter of systematically getting in, making a start and getting out before making it count. Symptomatic of this was Jonny Bairstow, who provided Todd Astle with his first Test wicket for six years with a wild shot to a long-hop, just a few deliveries after having been missed horribly by Trent Boult slogging wildly at another long hop: what Geoff Boycott must have been saying while watching, does not bear thinking about.

Other traditions were observed too. After some encouraging performances in the ODIs that one hoped would kick-start his winter, Moeen Ali could offer neither runs with the bat, nor control with the ball. And, after England’s bowlers had bowled manfully, but with little threat for 141 overs, the pitch looked different when New Zealand bowled on it (how familiar this was from the Ashes Tests!) This has, possibly, been the most disappointing aspect of the winter so far (“so far”, because it may yet get worse): England were expected to use the conditions extremely well in both day-night Tests but, both at Adelaide and at Auckland, have been comprehensively out-bowled.

While the primary responsibility for defeat rests in that first innings of 58ao, it is not beyond the point that they bowlers did not exactly shine, themselves. Only when Jimmy Anderson and Stuart Broad – the latter, mostly unheralded, but went at just over 2-an-over for 34 overs and took three wickets – were bowling did Joe Root have any sort of control. Overton, Woakes and Moeen Ali had combined figures of 75-17-236-1. In contrast, in the second innings, the New Zealand support bowlers had 72.1-26-156-6: the difference in the threat posed was massive and meant that, while Anderson and Broad had to pound out 63 overs, Boult and Southee bowled just 53 in that second innings – an important difference when playing back to back Tests.

For the 2nd Test, England evidently are going to make two changes, possibly three. Things will depend to a degree on the fitness of Ben Stokes. If he is fit to bowl his share of overs, there will be room for an extra batsman. If he is not, England will have their options more limited by the need for an extra bowler that would lengthen the tail.

That Jack Leach will come in for Moeen Ali is taken as almost certain. Leach took 18 wickets in the three unofficial Tests v West Indies A. Leach is a genuine tail-ender, although he batted as high as #8 for the Lions, albeit in a line-up with a very long tail, and is beginning to show some notions of knowing which end of the bat is which (he batted for 98 minutes, mostly in company with Mason Crane as the Lions tried to avoid an innings defeat in the 2nd Unofficial Test). England have to take the plunge with Leach at some time and there are still many who think that, despite the issues over his action, he should have been in India last winter and, definitely, should have been in Australia.

That Mark Wood will replace, probably, Craig Overton, is another more than likely change. He averages nearly 41 with the ball from his ten Tests, but adds something of an X-Factor that has been sadly missing for England by being around 10km/h faster than anyone else in the attack. At Auckland, England had four right-arm, medium pace seamers, all bowling in the low-80s (MPH) and an unthreatening spinner: as was said of one particular England attack in the early ‘80s, “the captain could change the faces and change the ends, but not change the bowling”. There is a line of reasoning that Chris Woakes could make way instead but, his superior batting is likely to save him, given that the tail will, inevitably, be lengthened by dropping him. Mark Wood has a similar level of capability with the bat to Overton, so the change would not weaken significantly the tail.

If Stokes cannot bowl, the attack would be Anderson and Broad with the new ball, Wood as first change and, probably, Woakes relegated to fourth seamer, with Leach as spinner. The tail would long, with Woakes, Wood, Leach, Broad and Anderson from 7 to 11. In this case, Joe Root would stay at #3, with a top order of Cook, Stoneman, Root, Malan, Stokes & Bairstow.

In contrast, if Stokes can bowl, there is a real possibility that an even more radical change could be made, with Liam Livingstone coming in at #3, Joe Root dropping down to his favoured place at #4 and, most likely, Woakes missing out. This would allow England to play the extra specialist batsman to compensate for the lengthened tail and Malan to go back to his favoured place at #6. In this case, the XI would be: Cook, Stoneman, Livingstone, Root, Stokes, Malan, Bairstow, Wood, Leach, Broad & Anderson. England would play two debutants and recall a player who has be absent for nearly two years, as well as making two positional changes. That would certainly be enough for the pundits and the fans who are calling for radical changes.

Either way, England would field a better-balanced attack and will look at least two players who can provide new options, both for the summer and, looking ahead to next winter when two and maybe three spinners will be needed in the XI. The preferred way to go would undoubtedly be the option with Stokes taking a full part in the attack, if only as fifth bowler. Stokes’ back problems towards the end of his innings appear to have been only due to muscles complaining over unaccustomed effort after months of reduced activity. Asking him to bowl would be a calculated risk, especially with Wood’s long history of injury but, with Root, Malan and Livingstone all competent emergency spin options, England may feel that they have enough bowling cover available.

Either way, England cannot afford another defeat.
 

Meanwhile, in another galaxy, far, far away, Smith and Warner have received a one-year ban and Cameron Bancroft, nine months. Smith will not be considered again for the captaincy for two years and Warner, never again. As more details come out, the suspicion is that David Warner has been the worst offender: he will never again be considered for the captaincy and, one suspects, may have a hard job to win his place back in the side.

However, there is one item that I find unacceptable and that the apologists should too and that is the systematic lying of Bancroft. Even when he “confessed” he lied, when he would have received far more sympathy had he come out straight and said, “yes, it was a piece of sandpaper”. First he claimed it was a black cloth. Then yellow tape that he had covered with dirt. At no point has he admitted to what it really was… sandpaper! The attempt to cheat was clumsy and stupid. The cover-up was even clumsier and more stupid. And the systematic lies take the biscuit.

If Somerset do not revoke Bancroft’s contract, the sledging and abuse that he will receive from players and fans will be epic; it will be a massive on and off-field distraction to Somerset and will reinforce the suspicion – remember the raking of the Taunton pitch before the Middlesex match – that Somerset are willing to push the definition of fair play a little too far towards the limits.

As any proud Bristolian does, even though I was born on the Gloucestershire side of the river (by a couple of hundred metres), I claim Somerset as well and take pride in their successes, although Gloucestershire has been my county as long as I have followed cricket. I want to see Somerset win the Championship in 2018 as a retirement present for Marcus Trescothick, but I want to see them win it clean, without suggestions of sharp practice.

Friday, 19 January 2018

Ashes 2017/18: 1st and 2nd ODIs - Cricket Through The Looking Glass


 

Ashes 2017/18: 1st and 2nd ODIs

Cricket Through The Looking Glass

January 19th 2017

It has been an odd week.

The Crown Prosecution Service decides to prosecute Ben Stokes for Affray. This is a serious offence that can be tried in a Magistrates Court (3 magistrates instead of a jury) with a maximum sentence of six months in prison, or it can be sent for trial to a Crown Court for trial by jury with a sentence of up to three years. Stokes’s case has been sent to Bristol Magistrates Court so, with the possibility that the case might take a year or more to be heard, the ECB decided to re-commission Stokes when many fans and pundits thought that maybe he would not play again for England.

Significantly, Stokes will not go to Australia for the end of the ODI series and the T20s that follow; he will go for the follow-up tour of New Zealand where the press and the public are less hostile and the media tend to be far thinner on the ground anyway.

It is fair to say that not everyone favoured the decision and the ECB committee was deeply split. However, restraint of trade and maintaining a presumption of innocence were powerful arguments. Stokes has already been punished severely by missing a significant part of the ODI series against West Indies and the whole tour of Australia and stopping him playing while maintaining the image that he has not been convicted without trial, could be hard to justify in the courts.

Could it possibly be coincidence that the day after Ben Stokes’s date of return – February 20th – was announced, it was announced that this same date he would be required to present himself in court in Bristol?

It is possible that Stokes could manage to negotiate a change in date. He is going to contest the charge. It is also quite possible that the magistrates will refuse to accommodate him, media personality or not. It is also possible that he may enter the court on foot and leave it in a prison van, thus halting his return to the England side at Her Majesty’s Pleasure.

Watch this space. This one may run and run.

So, have England been further distracted? After all, in 2013/14 they lost all five Tests, lost the ODIs 4-1 and the T20s 3-0. Two of the ODIs were very, very close, but, of thirteen international matches on the tour, England won but one. They then went to the Caribbean for a T20 series… and lost that too. In other words, losing became a habit and the Australians were in no mood to let up even when the Ashes were won. It was thus not surprising that the book-makers had Australia firm favourites for the first two ODIs.

Yes, we expected a one-sided ODI series. And boy have we got it. A whitewash looks a pretty good bet. The novelty is that it is England who look to have a pretty good chance of imposing it. Yes, this is a mirror image of the Test series. Both games have looked closer on paper than they were on the pitch. England chased a ground record 305 to win at Melbourne and got them with some comfort. And, at Brisbane, despite a late wobble, a wholly inadequate 270-9 by Australia was chased down with more than five overs to spare. Australia look to need to set 330-340 to test England and are getting nowhere near that.

Even the Australian successes are a mark of their failure. Aaron Finch has scored 107 and 106 and both matches have been lost. Both innings though have been at under a run-a-ball: he just has not been able to accelerate and get away from England. In fact, today, until a late thrash from Carey, no one had come close to scoring at a run-a-ball and even Carey’s innings was 27 from 24. To have set an adequate target, someone had to score at 150 and get the scoreboard accelerating but, in a batting-heavy line-up, no one could. In the first game, Australia were 196-3 with 15 overs to go: a platform for 330+? Australia simply do not have that kind of vision. Only Stoinis, with 60 from 40 balls, threatened to play the sort of match-changing innings that we have associated with Australia and even he could not see it through. The last three overs produced 19 runs and three wickets. Today, seeing the way the wind was blowing, the CricInfo commentator almost begged for 50 from the last 4 overs to make a game of it: he got 20. Today, Bairstow, Hales, Buttler and Woakes all made significant contributions and all scored faster than Finch. It did not matter than Root’s innings was relatively slow: he anchored as runs came in a flood at the other end.

Part of the difference is the taming, at least thus far of Sir Donald Smith. Caught behind off Adil Rashid in the first game and LBW to Root today, he has made two starts, but not been allowed to get away either time. An important part though has been England’s spin pairing. Adil Rashid has been expensive but taken match-changing wickets. Eoin Morgan has been prepared to see him go for some runs in return for vital breakthroughs and so far his wickets have been Smith, Mitch Marsh (twice) and Stoinis. Today, a handy 209-3 with 10 overs to go, became 216-6 as Moeen Ali and Adil Rashid turned the match on its head. And there hangs a tail: Moeen Ali, 17-0-70-2 – of the bowlers who have bowled at least ten overs in the two games, comfortably the most economical on either side, with his nearest challenger Joe Root, who has only bowled today.

Moeen Ali and Adil Rashid are forming a middle over stranglehold with the ball. And so effective has Adil Rashid been that he was even entrusted with the ball in the final overs in the first game. Moeen looks a totally different player to the sad, lonely figure of the Tests. Add to it that the wicket-taking menace of Mitch Starc is being countered by the menace of Liam Plunkett and suddenly it looks like a different pair of sides. Starc has more wickets at a better average and strike rate, but Plunkett has better economy.

Steve Smith has admitted that Australia are well off the pace and lacking answers and will not have felt in any way relieved by Eoin Morgan stating that England have been well short of their best. And, truth be told, they have not batted anywhere near as well as they can, mainly due to their minimal preparation. With the third game back-to-back with the second, England should start to get into their stride. If they do, you would not bet against 5-0. As it is, Australia have to win the third match to keep the series alive. And you do not know how good it is to say that.